Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

  • Yes I decided to move on to a new project.

    Votes: 27 15.8%
  • No when I start a project I finish it.

    Votes: 94 55.0%
  • I finished it and sold it?

    Votes: 13 7.6%
  • The more I worked on it the more I realized needed to be done. So I got out before it was too late.

    Votes: 37 21.6%

  • Total voters
    171

ryanstandley

Recruit
Joined
Jul 11, 2007
Messages
4
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

I'm pretty new to the whole boat thing. Took home a free runabout off craigslist, and according to the latest count I've decided to give it away 4 times so far. Every time I end up back out working on the darned thing again. Rotten transom, rotted floors, waterlogged flotation foam and disassembled siezed mercruiser have all made me want to give up on it, but I haven't posted the ad yet =). Actually finally found some good news after I ripped up the old floors and dug out the nasty wet foam, the stringers are actually in pretty nice shape. First thing I've found that didn't make me want to give the thing away so far.
 

lmannyr

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 5, 2007
Messages
815
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

It's tough work but I think it will pay off. I'm the "what needs to be done" and "I'll figure it out" type of guy. I'll research the net, books, people, or trial with or with out errors. It's all fun. Learning new skills is the best part too.

At the end, I'll have another toy to enjoy with the family whenever it's done.

I'd rather spend 8k than 60 + k for a newer cruiser.

Keep those boats alive. Enjoy!!!
 

HONKER1

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Apr 1, 2007
Messages
245
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

Took me a year to restore my '86 Starcraft SS. Must admit I paid the professionals to do the technical stuff. But I learned a lot, and would love to do a complete restoration by myself. I didn't discover this website until I was done with the Starcraft. This website has the best information about boats on the planet. I feel I can do it with the help of all you fellow boaters.
Men with wives that understand our drive for boating are sure lucky. My wife questions my sanity about everything I add to the boat. I tell her it's a trade-off for everything she adds to the closet.
 

Tail_Gunner

Admiral
Joined
Jan 13, 2006
Messages
6,237
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

HMMMM after two projects and reading a current thread, i am ready for more punishment.
attachment.php



Ohh im sure im in for some major brain damage............ but i guess that's why i am here. Uhhh that should be the answer to this whole thread..........;)
 

drewpster

Commander
Joined
Oct 17, 2006
Messages
2,059
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

The terms "given up" on a project implies that one has become frustrated with the task at hand. That feeling of being over one's head or being too overwhelmed to continue.
If that is the context of the question, than my answer is no. I have never given up on a project because I felt I could not complete it. That would be contradictory to my nature. I take on these projects because I believe I can complete them. If I run into something that intimidates me, I try to educate myself. That's how I learn. That's the fun of it.

I cannot paint a boat as well as a professional. But I can make my paint job look better than any professional's. Does that statement seem bold? Well maybe it is, but I am my own judge and I say it looks better. I cannot build a boat. But I can repair any boat built. Bold again? Maybe, but I judge my work, and I say when the job is done.

The point is this, if you enjoy the work and you are proud of what you accomplish, finishing a project is secondary to that. You only fail if you do not give your best effort and enjoy the process. I hate to sand, but sanding has become my life's work it seems. I am giving it my best because that is what I enjoy. I could care less about fiberglass or epoxy resins. But I educate myself as best I can in pursuit of my goal. If I make a mistake I see it as part of the learning process and I try again. All the while I try my best to keep my eye on the goal, having fun, learning, and taking pride in the little accomplishments. I want to have a boat like none other, unique, my own. That's the goal and my only failure would be if I did not enjoy taking the challenge.
Never give up. Just move on. If it is not fun, its not worth it.
 

Nova II 260

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
681
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

Well said Drewpster;
For the record, when is a house, car, boat, project done?
dunno.gif
Once it is no longer in your possession?
For those of us that bought a "non" project boat. Why do we work on it so much?
Buncha fanatics !!
icon11.gif
icon10.gif
 

Rocky4052

Seaman
Joined
Jun 3, 2007
Messages
51
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

I guess the MFG ended up to be a NFG ???? :eek: {only kidding}

I hope I have better luck- and you have better luck on the next one. Dan
 

reelfishin

Captain
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
3,050
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

(I would swap any glass boat for an aluminum boat any day).

Such a small mentaltiy.....:D

I have gravitated towards aluminum boats simply since they are lighter and I can run a smaller motor, tow and launch with a smaller truck, and they use less gas.
I also think that aluminum is more durable for my type of use, I run it shallow, often stumpy waters and aluminum fairs better if you make bottom contact or have to beach the boat. I can also weld aluminum. I also like the fact that the wood that is used can also be replaced much easier than that of a glass boat, (all bolts and rivets on all the one's I've had so far).

I'd gladly swap my Renken 900, (which has a solid hull, floor, and transom), my Duo or Starcraft trihulls for aluminum boats. I tow with a 4 cylinder Ranger P/U and don't intend to buy any larger vehicles, especially with gas bouncing around the $4/gal. mark. I like the fact that I can tow my aluminum boat to the ramp 20 miles away and run all day on less than 10 gallons of gas.

Just the same, I hate to let any boat with potential go, but I can't keep all of them.
 

redfury

Commander
Joined
Jul 16, 2006
Messages
2,657
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

My boat is my hot rod. I had a "hot rod" when I got out of the Army, I found out that having a "hot rod" as your only car is :
1. expensive
2. impractical
3. expensive
4. expensive

Add in delivering pizzas in it as my source of income getting 6mpg, I ended up selling it after it nickel and dimed me to death.

My boat as my new hot rod is
1. expensive
2. practical
3. time consuming

But, I can take my time working on it as I don't need it to get me to work, so if this project takes me 5 years to complete, so be it. In the end, I DID THE WORK, and I'll appreciate it more than if I had just purchased a serviceable boat from someone.
 

i386

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,548
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

I know I haven't posted anything about my project in a while. I've been busy with other things. I have not given up though. It's really about what's between point A and point B, not getting to point B for me.
 

BoatBuoy

Rear Admiral
Joined
May 29, 2004
Messages
4,856
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

I know I haven't posted anything about my project in a while. I've been busy with other things. I have not given up though. It's really about what's between point A and point B, not getting to point B for me.

I know what you mean. I started one in 1985. But I haven't given up yet.
 

drewpster

Commander
Joined
Oct 17, 2006
Messages
2,059
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

My story is fairly typical of the gear head lifestyle. I have had countless projects since a very young age. The first being the rather foolhardy disassembly of an expensive toy dump truck the day after my 6th Christmas. Needless to say my parents only bought me toys I could get back together after that. Growing up I have always had the deepest admiration for guys who know how things work. As an adult, physically anyway, I am still taking my toys apart. Getting them back together has become more complicated.

I approach every project in terms of the tasks at hand. It is easier to start with step one and progress one step at a time through the project rather than jumping around from one thing to another. I work only on the given task until it is complete. Yes there is the occasional part purchase or minor prep work that pertains to other tasks. But for the most part I try to stay focused on the task at hand and only move to another when the present one is completed. If I attempt to take in the whole project, working on one thing then the other without completing something, that is when I get overwhelmed. Here the challenge is staying focused even when it is boring or uncomfortable. (sanding) I am at my best when I can look back over the job and know it is done. (mmmmm, shiney new boat!):D
 
Last edited:

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,081
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

That's a Tough to Answer, Trick Question......

I've got a Life Full of Projects that all vary from "Justa Thought",......
To "Completed enough to Use"..........

Even when I Think I've gotten to the end of a Project,..........
I find Another Improvement I can make.............:rolleyes:

Ayuh,.........
I got a Yard Full of Boats,+ I haven't given Up on Any of them............Yet.....:D
 

erikgreen

Captain
Joined
Jan 8, 2007
Messages
3,105
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

Well, I bought my first boat, a 22 foot sea ray, after being bitten by the bug when I started scuba diving. I wanted a boat big enough to survive 2-3 foot waves on lake superior in moderate comfort.

Of course, since I was looking for a cheapie, I wanted to spend $4000 or so and get something I could use with some work. So I thought myself lucky when I found a 22 footer for $1350 with a trailer. I took a day off, drove four hours to get it home, and put it into storage for three months, until I had a house with a driveway.

Then when I was working on the interior, I noticed the floor was loose over the gas tank. I started pulling at it and figured I'd replace it. Then I looked at the gas tank and it was rusted solid, so I thought I'd better replace that too. Pulling the gas tank, I noticed rusty stringers, so I thought, uh-oh. Pulled the whole floor to get to the stringers, and found a rotten transom. So I pulled the motor out, replaced the transom, replaced the stringers, got cleats glued to the stringers, and then gave up hope.

Why then? Well, scuba season came around again, and I realized I wouldn't see the water this year with that boat. Also, I saw another boat of almost the same type that was ten years newer on craigslist for $500. I went to check it out and the hull, floor, stringers, and transom were solid. It had a motor that was cracked, but I had a spare motor from the other boat!

So, I took it home, and worked on the motor with a friend. After getting advice here, I found out I couldn't use the other boat's motor - it was a ford, and the new boat was a chevy. I thought I could maybe fix the cracked motor. We even took it out on the lake for a day, the motor ran well enough for that. But on the way home, the boat on the trailer started to sway, jumped off the trailer, and wrecked the boat, trailer, and my pickup. Too much weight on the trailer rear.

I got the mechanicals on the truck fixed, didn't do the body work (the truck is a 2001, but it has 260k miles) and put the boat on blocks in my driveway. I'm almost done fixing the hull scrapes and dings, I have new parts to replace the motor mounts and transom plate that snapped in the crash, I have a pile of parts to put new brakes and bearings on the trailer, and I have been working hard on a used 350 chevy block for a month (bought on craigslist for $300).

Last night I found that the 350 block has a large crack in the head, and is unusable. So now I'm waiting to order a reman engine for the boat. In the meantime (until I have the cash) I'm going to finish the hull repairs and get the sterndrive's transom work done. I have all the parts I need (used) but I'll still have to do some work to make the new bell housing and transom plate go on properly. I have the new seals for it, and I'll use the outdrive from the 22 footer.

Then I need to do the trailer. Some painting, welding, and wiring.

Also, in purchasing the parts for the second boat I ended up with a third boat (don't ask) on a trailer.

So now I'm nearly broke (I make $86k a year in my day job) since the boats, parts, and the accident have emptied my savings. I am still determined that come hell or high water I will have a boat on the water this year. I have also damaged my finances by purchasing a side scan sonar on a contract - I set up the purchase to occur early summer, when I thought I might have a boat to use it with.

So, right now I have a ton of bills to pay, I have a few hundred dollars to live on until my next paycheck, I have three non-working boats in my driveway, a garage and house full of spare parts and repair supplies, the rest of the house is a wreck - not much furniture, piles of boxes everywhere (been working on boats since I got 'em, not my new house) and one wall half sheetrocked.

I'm not married. No girlfriend either. Wonder why? :)

I probably *should* give up at this point. I just refuse to. I'm basically broke, yet I'm planning on spending $1600 on a reman engine in a couple weeks.

I think I need help %-\

Erik
 

redfury

Commander
Joined
Jul 16, 2006
Messages
2,657
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

Yes Erik, you need help. Yikes! I've read your posts, and have followed along with your ride....

All I can say is, my wife better appreciate the fact that I'm taking my time on my boat when there is extra cash laying around to throw at it!

Good luck man!
 

jddenham

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 8, 2006
Messages
393
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

Good luck with that !!

I have gotten in so much trouble with boats that I now only spend money that I have made off of junking a boat and parting it out on ebay.

And I STILL get grumbled at !!


All I can say is, my wife better appreciate the fact that I'm taking my time on my boat when there is extra cash laying around to throw at it!
 

merc1

Seaman
Joined
Apr 7, 2006
Messages
67
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

I started my 2nd one this week a 1978 ranger 17.5. I have had the boat sence erly this spring but was still working on the first one. I have it all done and its nice but only 16 ft and and not as wide as the ranger. Ishould post pic's but seem's i never have time to . Maybe this time i will try to and the other one as well.
 

57whitehouse

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jun 18, 2007
Messages
519
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

I bought a 1965 super skeeter on a saturday. very oxidized paint (forest green). started polishing the side of the boat to a beautiful finish. finished 1/2 of one side and some guy bought if from me for 4+ times what i payed. didn't finish the project.
 

Attachments

  • skeeter14.jpg
    skeeter14.jpg
    22 KB · Views: 0

OV1961

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Aug 14, 2007
Messages
127
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

After a second bout with a scalpel wielding surgeon at the local hospital, removing more moldy stringer splinters. My bride (the checkbook captain) said I was finished with that project. "Park it and Sell" she commanded. Weakened from medication, I complied.

I haven't given up on mine, although it took 18 months for me to begin :p Luckily my boat was made before flotation foam. I will have to replace part of the floor and probably the transom. Maybe I'll have it done in 6 months.

When I was young I had fixer-upper cars and always drove them while fixing them; this boat will be the same. She won't be 100% done when I put her in the water but it will be good enough for cruising and fishing the rivers and tributaries.
 

Tail_Gunner

Admiral
Joined
Jan 13, 2006
Messages
6,237
Re: Has anybody started a project boat and gave up on the job?

I have gravitated towards aluminum boats simply since they are lighter and I can run a smaller motor, tow and launch with a smaller truck, and they use less gas.
I also think that aluminum is more durable for my type of use, I run it shallow, often stumpy waters and aluminum fairs better if you make bottom contact or have to beach the boat. I can also weld aluminum. I also like the fact that the wood that is used can also be replaced much easier than that of a glass boat, (all bolts and rivets on all the one's I've had so far).

I'd gladly swap my Renken 900, (which has a solid hull, floor, and transom), my Duo or Starcraft trihulls for aluminum boats. I tow with a 4 cylinder Ranger P/U and don't intend to buy any larger vehicles, especially with gas bouncing around the $4/gal. mark. I like the fact that I can tow my aluminum boat to the ramp 20 miles away and run all day on less than 10 gallons of gas.

Just the same, I hate to let any boat with potential go, but I can't keep all of them.


I was just simply stirring the pot a bit, if alum is your passion that's all tha need's to be said. For myself i have worked around car's for so long i kinda hate metal. Or better said i can look at a metal boat and know what it take's to get to a end result.. I guess that say's something huh....:D

What i find fascinating with fiberglass is one can fix it with a just a litte sanding, glass and new paint, or if you dont like somthing you can just cut it out and reform something to you liking....it's the journey i enjoy. As we speak im in the second year of a recon...nope rebuild and redecorate. I have taken ideal's from car's other boat's, both old school cosmetic's and new.....only god know's where i am going to end up...

The Only Pic Of The Orignal

Picture095.jpg


Picture219.jpg



Picture260.jpg



Picture063-1.jpg



I thought i was done in that second pic, then i saw how just how good boat paint could be done so i took here all back down and went to work and really smoothing out the hull.
 
Top