Counter rotating props is a mis-nomer, it's counter rotating drives. You can't just switch a prop and magically you have a counter rotating setup.
You apparently have RH outdrives which is why you have RH props. You'd need to change one of the outdrives to LH before you need to worry about having a LH prop.
Leave it the way it was and you'll be fine.
Volvo or Merc drives? ( I suspect Merc's) Need drive#'s to help you.
But I just thought all boats with twins were suppose to have a left and a right to counter the push to the right.
As Bond-o say, not all twins got a reverse rotation drive. At some point, they used to have to use reverse rotation ENGINES! Yikes, what a pain. If the boat handles, steers, and performs okay with the two like drives, leave it alone and don't worry about it.