Info. search

Norm Malcosky

Seaman
Joined
Aug 14, 2002
Messages
70
Re: Info. search

Magster -<br /><br />As a matter of fact, I was reading a "Boating" or "Lakeland Boating" article about this subject last night. I will look up the reference for you tonight. It compared V-drives and Sterndrives.<br /><br />The stern drive won "hands down". Better fuel efficiency at cruise (by 20%) and better top speed (by 10 mph)for the same HP engine. However, stern drives had potential corrosion issues if stored in salt water. The shaft drives do not have such a large corrosion problem. <br /><br />The article compared three identical boats powered by a 260 hp mercruiser stern drive, a 260 hp merc V-drive, and a 300 hp merc V-drive. The author concluded the running gear of the V-drive (struts, shaft, propeller hub) and the thrust angle of the V-drive contibuted to the lower operating efficiency. The V-drive hulls also had a prop pocket (tunnel) to reduce boat draft. A straight inboard drive would probably have an even greater thrust angle and boat draft.<br /><br />I have operated twin stern drives for more than 12 years on the Great Lakes and would not chooe to change to either V-drives or straight drives. I often choose to operate in shallow water (this season was very bad on the Great Lakes) and inboard drives would either hit the bottom and destroy the props. <br /><br />Happy boating, think Spring - <br /><br />erie_guy
 

Norm Malcosky

Seaman
Joined
Aug 14, 2002
Messages
70
Re: Info. search

Magster -<br /><br />Couldn't find the magazine last night in Columbus home. I may have taken it to the L.Erie cottage. Will check over the weekend to see if I can find it.<br /><br />erie_guy
 

Mikedg

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 3, 2002
Messages
131
Re: Info. search

The article you are refering to was comparing identical Sea Rays with V-Drives and I/O's and yes the I/O's won for both speed and efficiency.<br /><br />If speed is the issue for you I think the I/O's are it. If excellent control around the docks is paramount you can't beat inboards.<br /><br />I currently run twin v-drives and love the handling but I do miss the speed and the ability to get into water shallower than 3-4 feet.
 

magster65

Commander
Joined
Sep 1, 2002
Messages
2,573
Re: Info. search

Actually, speed isn't a huge issue but with twins... fuel economy is. I've used boats in the past with twin straight shafts in a 32'. It handled great! Basically set the throttles to 1000 rpm and use the gears to dock. Are the stern drives the same? I have a Sea Ray with a single (alpha) and I can manouver it anywhere. I want a decent 8-10 knot cruise as well as the ability to get up and boogie. From what I'm finding out, stern drives seem to be the way to go. What advantage does the shaft have? :confused:
 
Top