Is this a bad idea or what?

[MarshMan73]

Ok I've had enough trying to get this old wore out 1986 175Blackmax to run right. So I need a new motor. I ran across a complete 1988 200Hp powerhead freshly re-ringed and bearings changed. It has been ran 4 hours on a dyno. I can get it for very little $$. I was told it would drop right on what I have now. However, is this a smart thing to do or should I get a newer model motor? I know a newer motor will get better gas mileage, but how much in real world numbers are we talking here? I like the smoothness and new look to the newer motors, but I know I won't be able to work on one of these computerized beasts, so that is going to cost when it does break. I like the reliability of an old fashioned carb and light the fire with as few ignition componets as possible.
What you guys think, repower the dinosaur or move on to the next century?

 

[Barnacle_Bill]

Re: Is this a bad idea or what?

If you can get the power head for a good price, go for it. Parts are generally still readily available for that vintage motor.