Re: Knocking under a load
This is probably why doctors won't make a diagnosis over the phone and offer prescriptions
But we try it here!
Not quite a dead give away, Robert! Sometimes with loose rod rollers (for whatever reason), the engine will idle fine but upon acceleration, the rollers will slide over the crankpin rather than roll, and give a screetching sound. Sometimes they will rattle. Detonation sounds like a rattle while bad bearings generally sound like a deeper knock. So when someone describes a knock, never assume anything without questioning every possibility.
This is probably why doctors won't make a diagnosis over the phone and offer prescriptions