Mercury vs Yamaha?

[jamesdeanj]

I just bought a Zodiac Futura Mark2 HD. I found a 40 hp motor in both Mercury and Yamaha within a few hundred dollars of each other. Which would be a better motor?

 

[JB]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

That is a Ford or Chebby question around here, James.

Get the one that can be serviced locally by a reputable shop.

 

[jamesdeanj]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

Would a 30 with power tilt and trim be better than a 40 with manuel? Does being able to adjust it on the fly help compensate for 10 less hp?

 

[TOHATSU GURU]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

Yes.

 

[Silvertip]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

It's also worth more when you sell it and appeals to a larger market. In other words -- it will be easier to sell.

 

[kenmyfam]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

I just bought a Zodiac Futura Mark2 HD. I found a 40 hp motor in both Mercury and Yamaha within a few hundred dollars of each other. Which would be a better motor?

The Evinrude LOL

 

[mickjetblue]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

Purely coincidental that I called and talked with a guy about a Merc 40/30
jet motor last night that he is selling. I thought the $3,000 price was a bit
high for a 1995, but he kept talkng it up for its positive attributes.
Finally, I again asked him why, if it was so great, he was selling it, and he
said, "I'm going to a Yamaha this time". Same size motor.

I've heard the same said about Fords and Chevies, too, but this was just too timely
with your question to not let it out!

 

[jamesdeanj]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

I like both Ford and Chevy trucks as much as anyone else, but I know that when a Ford breaks down it's harder to get parts and it's almost always more expensive. I've been in the body shop and mechanical business for years so this I know. This was the basis for my question. I'm sure people like both Yamaha and Mercury's and it might be for personal reasons or taste, I was looking for actual pros and cons. $3k-$4k is alot of money for me to spend. I can't afford to have to do it twice.

 

[rocket1968]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

Actually fords are easier to get parts for, there are alot more of them in the junkyards for parts. (I own a ford explorer and have no problems getting parts from that source).

 

[jamesdeanj]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

Actually fords are easier to get parts for, there are alot more of them in the junkyards for parts. (I own a ford explorer and have no problems getting parts from that source).

This can only mean a few things.

• There were more Fords originally (doubtful)
• Ford drivers are worse drivers
• Fords broke down more
• Chevys were worth more so they were fixed

So based on this theory: Are there more broken down Mercurys or Yamahas?
I'm not trying to be a jerk, I want to know some pros and cons to both before I go and spend $4000.

 

[ziemann]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

The reason you aren't getting the answer you want is that these types of questions are asked several times a day here. Are we talking new or used motors? How are you going to use it? Do a search and research your answer.

These guys tried to give you an answer based upon the info that you gave them.

With all things being equal, base the purchasing decision on the dealer that you feel will provide you the best long term service.

Good luck to you.

 

[jamesdeanj]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

Sorry I did not provide enough info. I'm talking about new, current model motors. I'm mainly going to be using it in San Carlos, Mexico in the Baja of California. We are going to be using the boat for diving and snorkeling mainly.

My question is, is there a reason to avoid a particular motor (30 - 40hp, Mercury-Yamaha, 4 stroke), or is it a personal preference?

I did some searching but I can't seem to find anything about specific problems that the new motors may have.

 

[scoutabout]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

I'd second the vote for going with the best parts and service network in your boating area. We all like to get up on our hind legs and bleat about our favourite makes but I'd say if you are going from new everything within a certain class is really going to run pretty much the same and last pretty much the same.

Decisions with bigger impact on your boating come when you need to decide things like 2 versus 4 stroke, inboards / versus outboards, jets versus props -- those kinds of things. If you were buying used I'd say past history and care can easily trump make of motor.

None of this applies to you so...stop worrying...and go out and get the Yammy

 

[fuzzeywiggler]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

For me it depends on the dealer and your proximity to the dealer.
Hope that helped...

Fuzzey

 

[Snowdrggn]

Re: Mercury vs Yamaha?

From personal experience:

60's 50hp Merc, Started 2nd pull cold (yes, manual start), never left me stranded.

1976 Evinrude 4hp weedless, runs a couple hundred hours a season without a sputter.

1988 Yamaha 25hp, Starts 2nd pull cold, still has never let me down.

1989 Evinrude 15hp, Starts 3rd pull cold, still has never let me down.



Best brand:
Any mainstream brand that has been carefully maintained and serviced, that has a good dealer handy. Preventive maintainance and good clean fuel and oils are the key!


Cheers,
Snow.