MFG with keel damage?

mfgniagara

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
92
I looked at a second MFG today, this one slightly larger than my Niagara which measures 15' 8" long.
The boat looks like a time machine back to 1960 something, the upper and interior is like new other than the lack of seats.
The bad part is that the trailer is crap, the boat is sitting on roller bunks with wooden rollers, and the keel rollers have all but turned to mush.
Here's where the problem lies. The keel has been dragged over the bad rollers for some time, there's some sort of patch spackled all over the length of the keel which has again been scraped off by the bad keel rollers. The rollers are so far gone that the bracket edges are higher than the rollers.
I'm not sure what they used to try to fix the damage but it looks like wall plaster or cement. Its white and chalky and scrapes off pretty easy. The good part is that the damage hasn't dug into the fibers, its just removed the smooth finished layer of the hull, I guess that's called the gel coat.
I can get the boat for next to nothing, it runs, and the trailer can be fixed or replaced. My question is what is a proper repair and how much of a hassle is it to handle. I was thinking just using epoxy to fill and smooth out the damaged keel, tinting the epoxy with white pigment to make it less noticeable? Then add a keel guard for future protection. The hull is light, has no water in the lower hull, and ran and floats fine. I'd say I'm at least 90% certain its just cosmetic, damaged area is about 1/8" to 1/4" wide and along the entire hull back to about the second from the last cross member on the trailer. There is no other hull damage at all.
Although it's cheap, I certainly don't want to bother with a leaky hull or a hull which has been strength compromised in anyway. The motor is only an older 50hp, electric shift, which would no doubt be upgraded but it does run fine for what it is now. The trailer is painted and surface rusted, and needs tires, springs, rollers, and paint work. I'd most likely just put the boat on a new galvanized trailer.
 
Last edited:

mfgniagara

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
92
Re: MFG with keel damage?

I didn't buy the boat yet. It's about 40 miles from here.

The damage on it though, to me, looks more like the white surface was worn down not gouged out or scratched. I don't see any point where the fibers are torn or exposed from within the resin, they are just visible now that the white is worn off. There is a few edges that look like broken eggshell but nothing deep. My concern is just that it's over such a long area in a high wear area. If it were a small spot, I'd lilkely just use white Marine Tex and fill and sand it and be done with it, but it would take a hundred of those little bottles to fill in what amounts to about 8' x 1/4" or so of damage.
 

Bob_VT

Moderator & Unofficial iBoats Historian
Staff member
Joined
May 19, 2001
Messages
26,065
Re: MFG with keel damage?

I saw one on CL today in VT for $100 w/o a motor or trailer but........ since you are in a secret place (no location stated in your profile) I doubt anyone could lend you a lead ;)
 

mfgniagara

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
92
Re: MFG with keel damage?

I'm in NJ. Vt is a bit far to go for a $100 boat unless it's super nice. The gas alone would make that a pretty expensive hull.
The boat I looked at is actually in DE, I found it while driving along a back road going to look at another boat.

The MFG that's listed on VT CL is also a Niagara, the one I looked at was a Westfield, which is a 16' version of that style hull.
I have one Niagara which needs a new transom, I'll most likely get to that soon. The idea of the slightly larger Westfield would have been nice but I think the transom repair will be less work then an outer hull repair on the Westfield.
The Niagara in the pic looks to be newer than mine, it has a different dash style which I believe came about in the later 1960's or so. Maybe even an early 70's model. I'm not sure if the newer models also use the all glass lower hull construction or not?
 
Top