Good work on both...aren't you guys worried about blinding someone on a hot, sunny summer day at the ramp?
The black gunk is not from burning it, that's the aluminum being removed from the surface mixed with the compound, you'll get black residue on anything that rubs against aluminum.
This is a popular product for keeping aluminum finishes looking good.
http://www.sharkhide.com/
once you get it polished out, you can put a coat of por15 glisten clear on it... use the etching cleaner and I wouldn't be surprised if it stays on great. So far it's staying on all kinds of things I put it on last year (polished metal)... It's pricey, but I'm thoroughly impressed... mag wheels, polished aluminum exhaust manifolds, a stainless prop (out of curiosity)...