On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

fbpooler

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
334
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

That formula is for a certain hull shape. Put that amount of HP on a non planing hull and you are just wasting power. The formula works for a deep vee which is a whole 'nother world than the SIB.

As far as planing speed goes, where does the 20 MPH come from? I have had a 16 ft canoe on clean plane with a 4 HP and the speed was much lower, but it was foolish for me to do that in a canoe. Talk about riding on a rail!! I have also had a 21 ft cuddy cabin on plane with trim tabs and it was going very, very slow with darn little wake. A 9.8 on an inflatable would have run rings around me.
 

Mlmg

Cadet
Joined
Feb 1, 2012
Messages
24
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

go down in size and put a bigger motor on it. a 10.5ft with two people and a dog strains to get on plane with a 15HP. its also a handful when unloading/loading. get an air floor for going solo.

I have a Zodiac 340 and have used a 15 Hp and 20 Hp.,,with two adults (And I am much larger than the average guy) and two kids, ages 9 and 12 "I planed" no problem, no hesitation...
 

Sea Rider

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
12,345
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

Yeap but that's a 340 along as much as a 20 HP. A 4 strokes 20HP on a 10.5" is too heavy. It's insane to suggest a larger HP than factory recommended on a smaller size sib, will have nervous behaviour and response when trying to plane, worst if being lightly loaded. We use 2 strokes Tohatsu 18 HP engines to test 310/320 sibs/ribs, with 2 up are bit scarry when at full throttle from a dead stop to achieve a fast plane.

Happy Boating
 
Last edited:

Sinistre1

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
298
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

My 340 got on a plane right around 11/12mph. Not sure where you got 20 from??? I could keep the throttle just right and as long as I hit no waves or wake I could plane all day at 12/13mph and at a little less than half throttle. The formula you are quoting has to be very specific and likely refers to a more traditional hard bottomed craft. Our boats are funny in that they weigh very little but present a boatload of drag... until over the planing hump and then they act more like a traditional hull.. especially when properly inflated. I stand by my earlier statement..a PROPERLY inflated, balanced, etc. 310 with a 15hp WILL plane with the weight you described, assuming it is properly distributed. It will also plane at a speed significantly less than 20mph. The planing speed is basically set by the shape, surface area and flexibility of the planing surface.... weight mostly only affects our boats in that they will sit lower in the water and present more drag surface to overcome. Weight CAN have a more pronounced effect if it is not properly distributed and it distorts the planing surface disproportionately (like adding a flap on airplane wing) thus creating a huge amount of drag that the boat/ motor combination may not be able to overcome.

It might be good to think of our boats like skipping stones. Take 2 stones... same weight, same shape... throw one at the correct angle, it will hit the surface, displace the right amount of water and continue to skip along... losing "power" with each skip until it doesn't have enough left to skip. Throw the other stone at too high or low an angle and it either digs in and loses all "power" fast.. or tries to pop straight up, again losing all "power" and sinking. Our boats need to be just right to do their skipping thing efficiently! :)

The direction that you are being guided in (Go down a size AND get a bigger motor) is counter productive. The smaller boat has less planing surface as well as weight capacity. It is more likely to "deform" with added weight and it is likely to be harder to get the space/ weight distribution issue squared away as you have limited space in which to accomplish that goal. Add to that you are now hanging an even heavier weight off the back and you are literally digging a hole in the water that your boat now has to climb out of!!

Now that i think of it.. if the person suggesting the smaller boat has a 15hp four stroke of substantial weight and has the 2 people sitting towards the aft of the boat.. it may not be impossible for him to prevent the boat from planing as he will basically be dragging the boats rear end through the water... To that poster... does your boat ride like it is doing a "pop-a-wheelie"?? Given that scenario, he would need to change the motor angle adjustment, probably getter a higher thrust prop and def redistribute the weight... all after ensuring the absolute optimal inflation!!!!

No contest... the bigger SIB has it all over in spades!!!
 
Last edited:
G

Guest

Guest
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

i can tell you this for a fact. I planed my 11.6ft zoom350s on A 6HP 2STROKE with a 20" shaft and a transom rated for 15. If i can plane a 6 with that much drag you can probably plane a 340 with 4hp and proper shaft size
 

Sea Rider

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
12,345
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

To achieve a fast plane, key is knowing how to ballance your sib properly along a healthy engine to overcome hull drag fast when going full throttle from a dead stop. BTW, a 2 stroke Tohatsu 18 HP will plane just anything faster...LOL!!

Happy Boating
 
Last edited:

ronaldj

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Messages
655
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

Thanks guys, told the wife what the replies were so far. When I told her 12' she said "12 foot, I'm on board with it" pun intended!

Did you get the boat yet?
If you did not you may want to look at the Saturn SD330W
It actually has more interior space than a 12 foot boat.
I was thinking about the dog having more room to move around
 

Chopperbill

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
389
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

Did not get one yet. Looked into the wide one but they don't to do much for me. Dog always stays close to my wife, kinda a mommy's boy and dosent move around much. Seems the twelves are out of stock most places that have a good price. Probably won't be until the end of the month. Going into surgery for my THIRD hip replacement shortly so I'm not in a big hurry.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2014
Messages
7
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

Did you get the boat yet?
If you did not you may want to look at the Saturn SD330W
It actually has more interior space than a 12 foot boat.
I was thinking about the dog having more room to move around

I had been looking at this one too myself while browsing the Kaboats that they have there. I wasn't sure about bringing my dog since it has an air floor. Is this ok to do? :confused:
 

ronaldj

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Messages
655
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

It should be ok. Just put down a piece of carpet or a floor mat for the dog
 

Sea Rider

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
12,345
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

It should be ok. Just put down a piece of carpet or a floor mat for the dog

And have his nails trimmed round at a dog's beauty salon, just in case he gets really excited while boating...

Happy Boating
 

ReelSlow72

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
36
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

And have his nails trimmed round at a dog's beauty salon, just in case he gets really excited while boating...

Happy Boating

i've taken my big boy (100+ lb pitbull/mastiff) out on one of those SUP inflatable paddleboards - and despite the damn near 300lbs we was it did alright. Big fella aint one to do much but lay down and relax when we was cruisin, but was nice to see his nails didnt even scratch that there PVC
 

JohnnyRudeClassics

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
80
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

i can tell you this for a fact. I planed my 11.6ft zoom350s on A 6HP 2STROKE with a 20" shaft and a transom rated for 15. If i can plane a 6 with that much drag you can probably plane a 340 with 4hp and proper shaft size

I have a 365 Class SIB.
An old 1970 Johnson SeaHorse 4 HP with the weedless drive
will put that boat up on plane at about 6.5 mph if I use a long
tiller extension such that I am sitting on the forward bench,
i.e. the boat is trimmed properly.
( the motor does seem loaded down, but that is an issue for another thread )
 
G

Guest

Guest
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

I have a 365 Class SIB.
An old 1970 Johnson SeaHorse 4 HP with the weedless drive
will put that boat up on plane at about 6.5 mph if I use a long
tiller extension such that I am sitting on the forward bench,
i.e. the boat is trimmed properly.
( the motor does seem loaded down, but that is an issue for another thread )
Welcome to the forum and thanks for the imput!!!! keep posting
 

JohnnyRudeClassics

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
80
Re: On the fence 11 or 12 foot?

Welcome to the forum and thanks for the imput!!!! keep posting

Thank you for the greeting.
Salut!
I have learn a ton of stuff off of the iBoats forums
and if possible I would like to make productive input.

With an old 1963 Evinrude Fastwin 18 HP
64fastwin.jpg
( looks like something George Jetson would own )
that 365 class SIB makes an easy 19 or 20 mph on plane
( 365 as in centimeters is 11 foot 11.7 inches, just under 12 feet as far a registration goes :)
with 800 to 1000 lbs total
boat + motor + fuel + gear + cooler + passengers/crew - all on board weight,
and again, properly loaded / trimmed
( though she was priorly in pontoon boat service )
( the motor does not seem tired at all, as it is no problem for her to )
( put a typical 14 foot deep v hull loaded up with 3 fishermen )
( all their gear and a cooler for an afternoon of fishing up on )
( plane at 22 or 23 mph)
( she just seems to drink a lot of fuel: 3 or 4 gallons per hour )
( where I think it should be more like 2 [topic for another thread] )

I never shoot it out of the hole,
just roll on the throttle
and she comes right up on plane.

I also do not stay or go on plane in any sort
of rough conditions at all. That old 18 HP OMC
design was the foundation for later 20 and
25 HP models where essentially all that was
done is that the top end was widened ( the
motor was able to turn more RPM's without
loosing too much torque, thus generate
more HP, via carburation, induction, and
exhaust improvements). As such not only do
I fully appreciate the low end torque
characteristics of that old 18 HP Evinrude,
as it is very commanding in rough conditions,
but based on my experience with it, I would
have to say in a brand new motor for a 365
class SIB, you really ought to be looking in
the 18 to 30 HP range, maybe as low as
15 HP. It is just too bad though the new
motors weigh so dang'd much, that Fastwin
weighs about 85 lbs.

I might be going out on a limb here in ignorance of forum rules and etiquette as far as linking goes,
but Duckworks has a really interesting article on water skiing ( including construction of )
Duckworks
that includes some graphs depicting the performance of a given hull versus
combinations of different motors & different loads ( passengers and water skiers ).
The page for the 35, 18, and 10 HP outboards
http://www.duckworksmagazine.com/05/columns/max/6/waterski12.gif
is very indicative as to just how easy it is to bog down a 10 HP motor.
There is also some illustration of how different props may help boost
performance somewhat or result in an over RPM situation.

BTW
Max's other articles basically led the way to my stumbling upon what great motors those
old 18 HP OMC's are. I started reading like crazy about old OMC outboards as I was
studying for the purchase of what turned out to be that 4 HP Johnson I commented
about earlier on in this thread. Max's articles are also the beginning of what lead me
to purchasing a SIB. I desired an old 18 HP OMC, but what is the point of having an
( well, that and memories of the Ole LoneStar Saratoga with the Evinrude 40 HP Lark on the back of it)
outboard and nothing to put it on. I already was paying for storage of a sailboat ( that
is what I bought the 4 HP for ), if I was to get another boat, I needed to be able to
"hide" it in the garage at the condos... Turns out a cheapie chinese vinyl 365 class
SIB with aluminum floor fit the bill and budget perfectly.
 
Top