Re: premium gas in a 140hp V4?
I am not a guru, but I will weigh in with my thoughts.
First and foremost, I would pay attention to what the owner?s manual states as far as octane requirements. Having said that, there are a number of schools of thought. Pre-ignition due to inadequate octane is a killer. It can break ring lands on the pistons. On the other hand, in general terms outboard motors do not have high compression ratios except for the few racing variants. The idea that higher octane is always better is not really true. Octane is a measure of resistance to detonation or explosiveness. Higher octane means a somewhat muted tendency towards explosion, which is great if your motor requires it. If your motor does not require it, that is the muting of the explosive tendencies done to thwart pre-ignition, then you at least are throwing away good money needlessly. Also a lower octane fuel may actually lead to easier starting, all else being equal.
Now beyond that, it can also be a regional thing. Where I live in southern Ontario, Canada, Shell uses 10% ethanol in the 87 octane fuel, 5% ethanol in the 89 octane fuel, and no ethanol in the 91 octane fuel. Other locals and other brands may have entirely different rules regarding ethanol. Has your motor?s fuel system & fuel lines been gone through regarding ethanol tolerance? If everything in the fuel system, from floats to lines, fuel pump diaphragms to primer bulbs are ethanol tolerant, then run whatever you feel comfortable with. Just make sure the minimum octane requirements are being met.
Motors that have had their heads & blocks surfaced may end up with slightly higher compression than when originally built. Also the presence of carbon after a period of running may also contribute to higher octane requirements. I haven?t even broached the subject of altitude & thinner air.
As a minimum you need to ensure that the proper heat range of plug is being used, your motor is properly tuned & timed, and all carbs are pulling equal weight & compression is within the proper variances between cylinders. It really doesn?t hurt to run too high an octane as opposed to too low an octane.
My 2 cents.