Re: Prop recommendation
Yes you need lower pitch. To bring your rpms up all the way from 4,000 to 4,800, I suggest you drop all the way to a 17.
Unlike previous poster, I believe you'll find that the improvement in holeshot you experience by losing 4" of pitch will be dramatic...with any load...,my previous 3.0L 18 footer could easily pull a 200 pounder out of a deep water slalom start, QUICKLY...boat planed out in less than 4 seconds.... with 5+ people on board. It couldn't DREAM of doing that when I bought it, but after I propped it correctly, it had no problems with heavy loads whatsoever. 3.0's are more capable than many people give them credit for. But they are very sensitive to incorrect propping, and MANY are propped flat wrong...like yours.
I do agree with the recommendation of "try before you buy" if at all possible. Find someone willing to loan you a used 17 pitch prop or somethign first....or one that will at least permit an exchange if you find that a 17 over-revs...
3 blade or 4? I'm a big fan of 4. But anything in a 17 will be a dramatic improvement over your current 21 pitch.
You are misinformed about Smart Tabs. If you buy the proper size and install them correctly, they do NOT constantly drag. They fold up out of the way at top speed and therefore they do not impact top speed. Anyone who says they drag at speed has too-high-force rated shock absorbers installed, and should contact Smart Tabs for a parts exchange....
I suggest you reprop first and get your RPMS up to as close to 4,800 as you can. Then assess your need for Smart Tabs after you are propped correctly. You are obviously way overpropped right now for your intended usage....