Rebuild or Replace???

rumrunner2

Recruit
Joined
Dec 27, 2007
Messages
2
I own a 2000 Evinrude 225hp FICHT engine. I was recently told by a local marine mechanic that I have zero compression on my #6 cylinder that basically, I have a blown engine. There were a few options, (1) buy a new engine ($14,200), (2) buy a rebuilt power head ($6500 installed), or (3) have the engine totally rebuilt (which they no longer do). Is it worth my money to have an engine this old repaired or rebuilt? The local dealer tells me it?s not because of the historical problems these engines have had. The only problem I had was with the "black box" which was covered under warranty. I just need some suggestions and recommendations.

Just a quick update ? I contacted BRP tech-rep who advised me, ?pre-1999 FICHT engines were troublesome, that?s what gave them the bad name. But from 1999 up, the FICHT were good reliable engines. BRP even stood behind OMC warranties on the 2000 and some 1999 versions. Plus, the current E-Tech engines are the hybrid of the FICHT engine which are very reliable.? His recommendation, ?have the 2000 FICHT rebuilt if it?s been reliable before this problem.? Some very strong words and encouraging hope to my depressing situation ? may need to consider rebuilding.
 
Last edited:

angus63

Captain
Joined
May 20, 2002
Messages
3,726
Re: Rebuild or Replace???

Welcome
Sorry bout the motor....
First thing always is to find out the source of the problem (what caused the loss of compression) before making any decision. What did the wrench say???
 

rumrunner2

Recruit
Joined
Dec 27, 2007
Messages
2
Re: Rebuild or Replace???

The mechanic didn't say what happened, the problem unknown. 'It would cost them additional man hours to find out and those cost would be passed to me with little benefit.' Not much help - sorry.
 

flabum

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 17, 2007
Messages
567
Re: Rebuild or Replace???

The mechanic didn't say what happened, the problem unknown. 'It would cost them additional man hours to find out and those cost would be passed to me with little benefit.' Not much help - sorry.

Well, if something caused that engine to pop and you re-install it onto the new powerhead, then the new powerhead will pop as well. Then you will be out another $6500.

Generally, when they replace the powerhead, it is just the long block they are replacing, all the electronics and fuel system is taken from the blown engine and put onto the new one.
 

flabum

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 17, 2007
Messages
567
Re: Rebuild or Replace???

To answer your question: If it were mine and I had the money, I'd go with a new engine. Maybe look into a Merc Optimax as a replacement....you will have to re-rig the boat for this, but with quotes in hand, a Merc dealer might match the price with rigging included.
 

tashasdaddy

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Nov 11, 2005
Messages
51,019
Re: Rebuild or Replace???

it it was anything but a Ficht, i would say rebuild. finding the cause of the failure.
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: Rebuild or Replace???

What Daddy said.

I would look for a BRP-made (post-2002) used Evinrude 225. Minimum complexity to change over.
 

kenmyfam

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Aug 10, 2006
Messages
14,392
Re: Rebuild or Replace???

I'm with the 2 posts above this one. Cut your losses and e-bay the good bits.
 
Top