Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

NathanY

Commander
Joined
Mar 16, 2002
Messages
2,408
What do some of you use in your 30-30's. With all the new cartridges on the market, I really dont know what to use. I want the best bang for my buck, no pun intended. :D The farthest shot that I will get is no more than 50-75 yards. I am a dead on shot and this rifle is a tack driver.<br /><br />So what do you all recommend?
 

dogsdad

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Messages
1,293
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Nate, there's not a thing wrong with the ordinary 150-grain soft point loads you can get at Walmart. Since .30-30 velocities are relatively low, there are no special requirements for the bullet. If you like, you can probably use the 170-grain load and get comparable results. Just don't go any lower than 150-grains. Cartridges from Winchester, Remington, or Federal will perform just about the same in the .30-30 Winchester. If you see something with premium bullets, that will work just fine also (although I am not sure they offer any such ammo for .30-30).<br /><br /><br />-dd-
 

Barlow

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Mar 11, 2003
Messages
1,794
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Nate, if you're using a 30-30 and your yardage is 75yrds and under go BIG!!!!<br /><br />Federal's 170 grn @ 2200fps at the muzzle ...<br /><br />but, this depends on how your particular rifle eats 'em ...
 

pjc

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
1,856
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

I'll also recommend the 170 Gr. FP (flat point) in Rem, Winchester, etc. 150 is just too light imo. <br /><br />I myself handload 170 Gr. Hornady RN bullets driven to 2650 fps muzzle velocity for my Sported Mauser Mod. K98 (8x57 Mauser cartridge). I also have relatively short range. That 170 has never failed if I do my part. <br /><br />The 3030 is a real fine whitetail cartridge. Our forefathers killed lots of deer, as well as bear, elk, and just about all North American big game with this cartridge. There ability to "hunt" close to game is what brought results.
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

I agree with Pat.<br /><br />I would use 170gr. bullets for those short shots. They are probably in the woods and will anchor a buck quicker than 150gr.
 

aspeck

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
May 29, 2003
Messages
19,121
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

I go with Pat also! With them bigger slower cals, bigger is better - to a point. 170g in the 30-30 is about that point.
 

NOSLEEP

Commander
Joined
Oct 30, 2002
Messages
2,442
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

What are you shooting at Nate?
 

Bob_VT

Moderator & Unofficial iBoats Historian
Staff member
Joined
May 19, 2001
Messages
26,065
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

I am a heavy bullet fan myself. I would go with the 170gr. <br /><br />Any brand with a PSP will do. Just use a few and see where they shoot... at 50-75 yards the drop is so slight it won't matter ....unless you miss.<br /><br />Bob
 

NathanY

Commander
Joined
Mar 16, 2002
Messages
2,408
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Originally posted by NOSLEEP:<br /> What are you shooting at Nate?
Anything that walks out in front of my stand that has horns. :D <br /><br />Seriously, mostly Whitetail, but will take a black bear if the opportunity comes up.
 

Link

Rear Admiral
Joined
Apr 13, 2003
Messages
4,221
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Nate I'm glad you asked about this<br /><br />Ok since I'm not a expert here maybe I can learn a thing or two.<br /><br />I went with 170 grain soft point because on a chart it had bigger knock down power father out.<br /><br />However when using a spin chart that shows the different cartridges for a 30-30 it shows at a 100 yards or less the 150 grain actually has more knock down power than the 170 grain?? <br /><br />I was planning on using 150 grain this year since seeing this because all of my shots when brush hunting are 25-100 yards max.<br /><br /> :confused: in Lakewood<br /><br />I could be confusing the numbers thats on the thing also. Pat Campbell since you hand load could you shed some light on this?<br /><br />Just got a phone call and must leave but when I get back tonight I'll find that spin chart and give the actuall funny numbers on it.
 

ratracer

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 10, 2004
Messages
232
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Link: the bottom line is that with the .30-30 the differences in kinetic energy and in trajectory between the 150 and 170 gr flatpoint bullet are too small to be meaningful at anything near a reasonable hunting distance, which is about 150 yards or so in this caliber. You just can't make a bad choice.<br /><br />Here's some data from Remington's web site. I'm sure there would be some differences if you went to Federal or the Winchester ammunition website, but the general results would be the same.<br /><br />At the muzzle the 150 gr bullet has more kinetic energy, but by 100 yards out the 170 gr has more energy retained. <br /><br />At a 100 yard zero the difference in bullet drop is less than an inch even out to 300 yards. If you go with the often-quoted figure that the bullet should have at least 1000 ft-lbs of energy left when it strikes a deer either bullet is good out to nearly 200 yards.<br /><br /><br />Cartridge Type Bullet Muzzle 100 200 300 400 500 <br />Remington Express 150 SP CL 2390 1973 1605 1303 1095 974 <br />Remington Express 170 SP CL 2200 1895 1619 1381 1191 1061 <br /> <br />ENERGY (ft-lbs) <br />Cartridge Type Bullet Muzzle 100 200 300 400 500 <br />Remington Express 150 SP CL 1902 1296 858 565 399 316 <br />Remington Express 170 SP CL 1827 1355 989 720 535 425 <br /> <br />SHORT-RANGE¹ TRAJECTORY* <br />Cartridge Type Bullet 50 100 150 200 250 300 <br />Remington Express 150 SP CL 0.2 zero -2.4 -7.6 -16.1 -28.8 <br />Remington Express 170 SP CL 0.3 zero -2.7 -8.3 -17.1 -29.9 <br /><br /><br />You can look it up, or any other centerfire cartridge that Remington offers, here: http://www.remington.com/ammo/ballistics/ballistics.htm
 

ratracer

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 10, 2004
Messages
232
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Dang! double posting, this isn't my night. :eek:
 

ratracer

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 10, 2004
Messages
232
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Goldang. Double post.
 

dogsdad

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Messages
1,293
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

The 170 will retain more of its velocity, and therefore more of its kinetic energy, when the range becomes long enough even though it starts out around 200 fps less than the 150-grainer. The 170 will probably penetrate a little better than the 150 also, but it might not expand like the 150 at shorter ranges.<br /><br />I seriously doubt any real performance difference on deer at short range between the two, but I'd go with the 150 on deer if I expect shots of less than 100 yards. I do agree that the 170 should provide superior penetration, but penetration is not the only consideration in selecting a bullet.<br /><br />I'd also add that a 170-grain bullet for an 8mm Mauser is not the same as a 170-grain bullet for any .30 caliber cartridge. Apples and oranges! And if they were the same bullet, you would need to recognize the difference in performance potential because the 8mm launches at 2650 fps, while the .30-30 is limited to about 2200 fps.<br /><br />-dd-
 

Link

Rear Admiral
Joined
Apr 13, 2003
Messages
4,221
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

ratracer <br /> dogsdad <br /><br />Excellent information. And thats what I saw or was looking at.<br /><br />Since the rifle is already sighted in with 170 and I still have a box and a half of ammo left I will just use it for this season<br /><br />DD<br />Agree that at close range like this your really not going to notice the difference.<br />But it is nice to know I retained a little of what I read
 

pjc

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
1,856
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

The reason 3030 bullets have flat points is due to tubular magazines that most rifles chambered for this cartridge have. Flat point bearing against case head ensures that bullet point will not impact against primer upon recoil, thus preventing cartridges in tube mag from going off.<br /><br />How a bullet works on game is "shock" (to nervous system) and "damage" (to vital organs, bleeding). For example, a lite bullet at very high velocity imparts much shock, but may not impart much damage. A heavy bullet at low velocity may cause much damage but low shock. An example, an arrows broad head provides some shock, but much damage, IE-bleeding.<br /><br />While ballistic tables and energy data are relevant and make for great discussion, bullet construction is more relevant. Energy transfer during impact with animal and the bullets retained weight after stopping or passing through are most important.<br /><br />Bullets intended for 3030 operating velocities have jackets of lighter construction to ensure proper expansion as well as weight retention properties. Premium bullet manufacturers (Hornady) will state that a .30 cal. bullet is intended for 3030 velocities for example, not to be used for 3006 velocities due to bullet construction (the lighter constructed bullet "blows up" upon impact at high velocities). That said, a heavy constructed jacketed bullet intended to perform at very high velocity would be the wrong choice for lower velocity cartridges (little if any expansion, energy transfer, and damage).<br /><br />The 150 gr 3030 bullet may be fine for average whitetails, higher muzzle velocities (shock). The 170 however, is a better choice in this case do to potential of a black bear or larger deer presenting itself. 170= shock as well as damage due to initial greater bullet weight as well as greater retained bullet weight (deeper penetration-more damage).<br /><br />BTW dogsdad, domestic US commercial 8MM ammo is down loaded to 2200-2300 fps muzzle velocity (170gr bullet) due to manufacturers recognition that there are many mil surp Mausers of questionable condition as well as recognizing that some early rifles had a .318 groove diameter barrel as opposed to the later .323 groove diameter. Norma offers 8MM hunting ammo loaded to the full potential of this cartridge, a 196gr spitzer bullet @ 2700 fps intended for big game hunting. Expensive and harder to come by in the US.
 

fishndvm

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jan 4, 2003
Messages
125
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

I dragged out my old 30-30 Winchester a couple of years ago and sighted her in at 100 yards. I used Federal 170gr shells, and had her dead on in the black or just outside on every shot. The next year, before the season began, I once again took her to the range. I had a few shells left from the Federal box, but when I went for a new box of ammo, I found only Winchester 170gr. To make a long story short, I learned a huge lesson. I shot tight groups with both brands, and windage was perfect, but at 100 yds, they were about a foot apart in elevation! 150 or 170? Dead is dead. But be careful when mixing manufacturers shells, no matter what the boxes say.
 

dogsdad

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Messages
1,293
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Pat, I did not check references on the 8mm load, just used the number you provided. I handload too, and there are instances where my loads are hotter than factory offerings also.<br /><br />That 8mm 196-grainer at 2700 fps sounds very impressive, especially out of a 57mm cartridge. That has got to be at the very limits of acceptable pressure.<br /><br />I stand by my advice to use the 150-grain load, but I do believe that the difference in performance betwwen the 170s and 150s, at least on deer, will be insignificant inside 100 yards. If the quarry is bear, I absolutely would go with 170s.<br /><br /><br />-dd-
 

pjc

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
1,856
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

OOOpppppsssssss...hey DD, that Norma load is actually 2500+ fps w/ the 196gr. bullet. Check out Normas site. Is interesting to see what the Euros are up to. Click on the oval Britt. flag looking icon for english verson of site.<br /><br /> Norma Web Site
 

dogsdad

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Messages
1,293
Re: Recommended Cartridge for a Winchester 94 30-30

Yeah, Pat...I kinda thought 2700 was pretty warm, but there's nothing cheesy about 196 grains at 2500 fps either. Sounds like good elk medicine!<br /><br /><br />-dd-
 
Top