Table Saw or Miter Saw?

jsfinn

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Nov 26, 2003
Messages
1,093
I have a lot of power hand tools but no bigger power tools. I have limited space to work and store tools, so I only want to buy either a table saw or miter saw to do odds and ends around the house (crown molding, chair rail, building outdoor furnature/storage, etc.).<br /><br />I know both tools have their advantages but right now I think that a mitre saw would cover me for most of my needs.<br /><br />Am I missing something? If you had to pick either a table saw or miter saw, which would you choose?<br /><br />Thanks!
 

BoatBuoy

Rear Admiral
Joined
May 29, 2004
Messages
4,856
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I have a table saw but it takes up a lot of room. From what you said, I'd prefer a miter for that work. Or then there's the radial-arm.......
 

1730V

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 14, 2004
Messages
563
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

The radial arm is an all around good tool. It will do everything you mentioned with good precision.
 

bayman

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 2, 2000
Messages
669
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

Any brand recommendations for a semi-portable radial arm saw?
 

jimr

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Mar 21, 2004
Messages
723
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I have a table, miter band and scroll saw. the miter is the newest and I like it.If you get a miter saw get a 12" Dewalt or good name brand
 

snapperbait

Vice Admiral
Joined
Aug 20, 2002
Messages
5,754
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I have both.. If I had to choose only one it'd be the table saw... <br /><br /> A good rip fence and miter gauge are the keys.. <br /><br />You'll be able to make fair to excellent miter cuts with a miter gauge... <br /><br />You'll be able to rip boards to width.. Makes much straighter cuts than a circular saw ever could... Cut grooves with a dado head blade...
 

one more cast

Captain
Joined
May 6, 2002
Messages
3,143
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I use my miter saw way more then I use my table saw BUT you can't rip lumber on a miter saw.
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I agree with 1730V.<br /><br />A radial arm saw will do just about anything any other bench mounted saw can do. Had a DeWalt for years. Not cheap, but a superb tool.<br /><br />If I had to choose table or miter I would go with a top line table saw. The chief advantage of the miter saw is semi-portability and ease of use on a job site.
 

Terry H

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 25, 2001
Messages
1,862
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

It really depends on what wants to accomplish. You can mitre with a tablesaw, but the blade is stationary, and you move the wood. Long pieces of wood are very akward. On a mitre saw you hold the wood stationare against a fence and move the sawblade, so you can mitre,or cutoff long pieces with relative ease. A tablesaw is at it's best with a good fence ripping boards to width. A mitersaw is strictly cutoff, no rip. A radial arm saw does not rip wood as easily as a tablesaw, but you can acurately rip boards, tho 4x8 sheets of plywood are difucult, but can be done. A radial arm saw will also cutoff and miter reasonable accurately. I have all three, and they get used most everyday. The Radialarmsaw hasn't been turned on in 5-6years. Mitersaw and tablesaw about even. If my tablesaw broke it would need to be repaired before I could go to back work, could live without mitersaw for a day or two if absolutely necessary...just rambling :)
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,082
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I agree with 1730V,+ JB.........<br /><br />A Radial Arm Saw will do Everything the other saws can do..............<br /><br />Craftsman is pretty hard to beat, for the Back-Yard Hacker Handyman...............<br /><br />The Rolls/Royce of power tools is Either Delta, or Dewalt...............
 

jsfinn

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Nov 26, 2003
Messages
1,093
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

This is great info, thanks for getting back so quick! <br /><br />I'm starting to lean more to a tabel saw. A radial sounds like the more ideal tool, but too big and a bit pricey. <br /><br />I guess what I forgot to mention is that I need something small enough to lug around and be portable.<br /><br />I have a townhouse and the deck is my work shop and my tools get stored in a closet in the basment when they arn't in use.<br /><br />I think I'll be making a trip to Sears this weekend to pick out my new toy.<br /><br />Thanks again, guys!
 

Maximerc

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 26, 2003
Messages
292
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I have the 8 in radial arm saw from sears.. had it for 10 years now its a bit smaller than the 10 in duhhhh I have been happy with it very versital. Not to say those miter boxes look sweet !
 

Paul Moir

Admiral
Joined
Nov 5, 2002
Messages
6,847
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

If you're looking at portable table saws, and by the sounds of it you are, then have a look at the Makita and the Delta while your shopping. If the new Makitas are anything like the old ones, they're indestructible but wonderfully accurate machines. One minute being abused running an abrasive masonry blade cutting up steel, the next doing fine carpentry. I've always liked the Deltas too, although I don't have nearly the experience with them as the Makitas.<br />I can't say I'm a big fan of the Craftsman ones though. Maybe I'm just unlucky, or maybe the ones in the 'States are better, but I've found them to suffer from strong vibrations. Settings would drift but maybe this was an effect of the broken control handles. <br /><br />Anyway, those are just opinions. Try to test the saws before buying them. See out how easily the rip fence sets up. Check for any play in the mitre slider since if it's not precise, you will not be able to make good cross cuts. If you can, run the saw and check out how much it vibrates. Set a pencil on it and watch it walk around. Run all the actions to their limits. Is it easy enough to wind the blade up and down? What effort does it take to set, say, 36°? Do they operate smoothly, and do they look like they will when covered in sawdust? Features are inconsequential.<br /><br />As for mitres - I've got a 10" DeWalt compound mitre. It's a tough, able and accurate saw. My favourite was either the 10" sliding compound Hitachi (expensive) which was a beautiful machine. Or the 10" (old style) Ryobi plain mitre which got dropped off a couple roofs, left out in the rain, cut steel, and still made nice accurate cuts in wood. 12" saws are nice - you can usually make a mitre in 2x6 in one cut - but good blades for them are pricey.
 

BoatBuoy

Rear Admiral
Joined
May 29, 2004
Messages
4,856
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

when I bought my Craftsman, I looked at Delta. It was absolutely identical to the Craftsman except for the name and the handle on the fence. May not be the same now. I bought the Craftsman cause it was on sale.
 

ndemge

Commander
Joined
Jul 15, 2002
Messages
2,644
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

Do you chop or rip more?<br /><br />I've got a Milwalkee Chop saw and a 15 amp dewalt circular saw with a rip fence. a table saw that could rip as good as the dewalt was WAY over the price budget
 

jamesgreen

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 9, 2004
Messages
128
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

My opinion go with the miter saw. A good miter saw for mouldings and trim work can't be beat. As for a table saw a good stright edge and some quick clamps with yor skill saw you can make some desent rip cuts in your larger material if the need arises.
 

boatneck

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Dec 9, 2001
Messages
107
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

jsfinn,<br />I had a basement full of stationary power tools and found that the table saw was best for ripping long pieces, the radial arm saw was good for cross cutting large pieces, and the chop/miter saw was good for carpentry. I had to move and get rid of all the tools and think if I had to keep one, I would have to think hard about what I would be doing--if you're building furniture, get a table saw. If you're doing general purpose stuff around the house, the miter saw is great, especially if space is limited. We build a 10 x 12 garden shed and the miter saw and jig saw did most of the cutting. I hardly used the radial arm saw and never for ripping--can be scary when it grabs a piece and impales it into the wall. Also, the table saw generates a ton of sawdust and even though I had a Delta dust collector, it still covered the basement with a fine coating. With a miter saw, you can take it outside and beat the sawdust problem. Good luck.
 

Barlow

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Mar 11, 2003
Messages
1,794
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

Sorry fellas. I totally disagree with the radial arm.. not a specified tool by any means.<br /><br />The blade/table relationship on the radial arm is the reason for this in ripping. <br /><br />-When feeding the material the blade is pulling the material up in the air and not against a table/surface. <br />-Ripping small pieces is a dangerous and painful task.. point blank.<br /><br />Cross cutting on one is less then desireable too.. especially when cutting miters.<br /><br />-Next time you're someplace or in the shop ... grab the handle of one. <br />-Pull it out past the fence <br />-Put slight preasure on the handle in a twisting motion .. you'll see what I mean.<br /><br />If its powered up ... <br />-flip it on and do the same thing<br />-watch the tooth edge on the blade.<br />Torque and centrifugal force/energy will cause the blade to 'walk' or wobble.. not cool when you're cutting expensive material and producing something that requires precise -no gap- joints.<br /><br />Precision, efficiency and ease of use are the main things here.<br /><br />A good 7-1/4" circular saw as stated before.. not a $40 'tin-table' model.<br /> <br />A good one... magnesium base table w/good -SOLID- incrimental adjustments, bevel cut abilities past 45 degrees (50 degrees +/-) and comfortable in your hand are key.<br /><br />I own Milwaukee and Porter Cable circular saws. Its a personal thing when talking tools but, there's no comparisons to be made to others.. keep the teal green stuff in the play pen. :p <br /><br />Lets not forget blades.. Carbide tipped only! Very important! <br /><br /><br />As mentioned before too.. ripping jigs or a rip guide. <br />-store bought is best but, if on a budget a 1/4"-3/8" thick length of flatstock aluminum works well with prior said clamps (tough ones to hold it in place tho).<br /><br />And finally .. invest in a high end, dual bevel sliding compound miter saw. <br /><br />Don't go radical and think 12" from the start.. 'blade walk' / wobble is a situation here too. <br /><br />*Buy the largest you feel you'll EVER need.<br /><br />-Hitachi's 8-1/4" is a good place to start. <br />-Makita's 10" is a solid choice.<br />-Makita's and Dewalt's 12" are hands down the most sought after.<br />-Delta's saws are good choices too but, I think you'll see that the Makita and Dewalt will be a little more user friendly and easier to operate.<br /><br />stay away from the 'toyish' lazer blade guides.. a few bumps and knocks and you'll need to re-adjust.. just something to get in the way IMHO.<br /><br />Remember carbide toothed blades with as many tyeeth as you can possibly afford or stomach buying. #1 thing in getting a smooth, clean cut. <br /><br />hope this rambling helps in the least bit.<br /><br />Good luck with the decision.
 

chuckz

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 22, 2004
Messages
625
Re: Table Saw or Miter Saw?

I agree with Barlow, dual bevel sliding compound miter saw. I had a Craftsman Radial Arm Saw, brand new, the motor burned up after 2-3 years of light use. I later found half a dozen others guys with the same experience. I replaced it with a 10" Delta miter saw and never looked back. (I bought the miter saw before the compound miters came out.) It's portable, versatile and dependable.<br /><br />I also own a table saw. Great for ripping.
 
Top