Tow 19' Boat w/Toyota? Your Tow Vehicle?

demsvmejm

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 4, 2004
Messages
831
Re: Tow 19' Boat w/Toyota? Your Tow Vehicle?

As JB said "You don't want to find out if your rig is safe from a hospital bed."<br />It does not, I repeat, DOES NOT matter how safe you drive, or how much space you give yourself to stop, accidents happen. Look at MajBach's post about the tire that wanted to be his spare. Where I launch is about 10 miles from my house. to get there is down a black-top curvy road. I came around one curve one day and there were five or six classic cars stopped on the paved shoulder. Now some of these people were smart and were way off the fog-line, others weren't. And here's some ***hole standing talking to the driver of one of the cars, on my side of the fog-line. With oncomming traffic present there wasn't much I could do but hit the brakes and pray. Somehow I managed to miss the idiot, blow the horn, stay in my lane, slow way down, avoid being rear-ended. God was my co-pilot, I'm sure. But the point is, YOU can't control other's stupidity. So safety is paramount. A smaller vehicle can't manage the forces and weight of the trailer as well as larger vehicles with larger brakes, tires (contact pattern) and stronger frames to keep it all together. Whereas I tow with a S-10 Blazer and have no problems to speak of, I'd love to have a full-size truck. I simply must balance my occassional need to tow with my daily need to commute and fuel economy (20-22 on the highway with no trailer).<br />So simply stated, safety is the first concern. And you can't possibly have a contingent for every possible situation, so you must play the balancing act. Here's one place that "Too much" is not possible.<br />Thanks for letting me rant.
 

JasonJ

Rear Admiral
Joined
Aug 20, 2001
Messages
4,163
Re: Tow 19' Boat w/Toyota? Your Tow Vehicle?

I once towed a 19 foot outboard equipped boat with an extended cab 4 cylinder Toyota 4x4. It got it done, but it was very hard on the truck, it was too difficult to stop and the tail really wanted to wag the dog. This was a one time only deal, and for less than 10 miles, just to get it to a storage place. Bad deal, and I am sure that boat weighed less than your rig. I personally run a fullsize Ford F150 ex cab 4x4, and like the fact that I can tow whatever I feel like safely.<br /><br />A car may have the same horsepower, and may be the same size, but a car has no frame, and was never built to handle heavy loads like a truck is. Any more, the SUVs are getting weak, being built on car platforms. There are few truck based SUVs anymore, the ones that exist are the really spendy ones. Definately keep the truck.
 

hise

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Aug 1, 2004
Messages
37
Re: Tow 19' Boat w/Toyota? Your Tow Vehicle?

My Isuzu Rodeo has been very reliable... in 92K miles, the only "break down" was the alternator went out - all other expenses have been maintenance only. I've towed a 20' Oday sailboat from PA to NC when I purchased it, and round trip from NC to FL. It gets 20 mpg with about 17 mpg towing. All of this is with my little 4 cylinder Rodeo.<br /><br />The V6 Rodeo should get roughly the same gas milage and tows 4500 lbs. Like JasonJ mentioned, many of the SUVs today are fluff on car chasis. The Rodeo is one of the few midsized SUV on a truck chasis.<br /><br />I'm a big manual trans fan. I downshift alot, especially with the boat. In my 92K miles, I've never had break problems. The Rodeo is the only midsize SUV I know that is maintains the same towing capacity whether is automatic or manual transmission.<br /><br />I could possibly be a Ford Explorer SportTrac (towing capactiy 5500 lbs) person if Ford would ever get their act together and offer a manual trans worth anything.<br /><br />Just my 2 cents.<br /><br />--Hise
 

Baldguy

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 30, 2001
Messages
174
Re: Tow 19' Boat w/Toyota? Your Tow Vehicle?

I towed my 17 1/2' bowrider with my 1988 Toyota pickup. It wasn't very comfortable, but as others have said, it got the job done. It was a 2 wheel drive and I was careful about the ramps I launched on as I didn't want to sit there spinnin the wheels trying to pull it out.<br /><br />I think the total weight of the boat was something like 2000#. Stopping distance, incredible.....and I could almost hear the engine and drive train crying at the misery I was putting it through...but it worked.<br /><br />Now I have a bigger heavier boat and needed something bigger to tow it with.....can you say HEMI? Defintely worth it.
 

DaveM

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Feb 27, 2002
Messages
308
Re: Tow 19' Boat w/Toyota? Your Tow Vehicle?

I like to observe others in hopes of avoiding mistakes. My boss used his Toyota 4Runner to tow a 20' bowrider with a 5.0L V8 (trailer brakes et al). He said it did just fine, and who was I to argue? <br /><br />Oh, perhaps I failed to mention that he had the main bearing replaced on his Toy after it started thumping like a bongo drum. Hmmm, could it have been related?
 
Top