Re: What prop pitch to run what rpm
Well, another prop question for the prop forum!
You have to know your drive ratio use a prop slip calculator and you must verify your tach and speedometer before you do anything with the prop.
http://www.go-fast.com/Prop_Slip_Calculator.htm
If your tach is correct, and the engine is otherwise running correctly (and you're not waterlogged or dragging an anchor.....

) you are WAY over propped. (pitch is too HIGH)
Put a 19 or 17p prop on it and see how it does..... I would do a 17 first.....
I used a 20p (19 re-pitched and cupped to 20) stainless steel prop on my previous King Cobra and ran 60 mph at 5000 RPM.
I still have it and a nearly new 17p stainless. (although it didn't run as fast with it.)
If you lived up here in the NW you could try them.
Did the engine EVER turn any faster with your current prop?...... if it did, you have something else wrong with your engine or boat.....