Holy moly. She’s way way under propped eh. Is the rpm limiter sounding an alarm on the dash ? Must have been some size of a man on the wakeboard that required that prop to pull him up !
I’d start with a 19” or a 21” and go from there. What’s on her now ? Must be like a 15” 5 blade or similar ? If your rpm and speed are accurate ?
I know a 1900 regal with a 4.3 mpi of a friends ran well propped with a 19” tempest plus on her alpha. Just around the 4800-4900 rpm wot at just a little over 50 gps. You don’t want too much pitch on these 4.3 MPi (if she is). They don’t have much grunt low down usually. Hope that helps.