Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Taxus812

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
177
Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive? There are not a lot of outboards in this area outside of fishing boats. I was curious if a boat with an outboard depreciates faster.
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,897
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Depends on the area. Locally, everyone wants an outboard or an inboard (saltwater). You can't give an I/O away.
 

smokeonthewater

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Dec 3, 2009
Messages
9,838
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Impossible question to answer without qualifiers....
 

Home Cookin'

Fleet Admiral
Joined
May 26, 2009
Messages
9,715
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Well for one thing with used boats, nothing has a high resale value, but some boats are lower than others!

I'm sure that will be very different in different regions. Also, when you are looking at the used market, you might not see the better boat since people will hang on to them, or sell them word of mouth, but the market may be full of the undesirables. In my market there are a lot of i/o's for sale but they are for sale because they are a mistake.

It seems to me that while a newer i/o may be preferred by some over a newer OB, once they are old, an older OB would sell better than an old i/o. They last longer, are easier to see if there are problems, easy to swap out or upgrade.

When you say "fishing boats" keep in mind that the center console design is a very good design for general recreational boating on the coast; few coastal boaters who knows their stuff would buy an i/o bowrider even if they never fish. So if you were looking around here, most boats are "fishing boats" to some but not used as such.

So another factor on resale is not necessarily the power plant but the whole design. Since i/o's are usually found in lake-boat bowriders, you may sell more i/o's in lake country based on the boat style and the opposite on the coast. There are a few models that go either way but not enough to really put them side by side on the used market.

Outboards on any boat are preferred here, so they would have a better resale value; you can't give away an i/o except to someone who just moved here from inland.

All also assuming in the small boat recreational market. Some people around here have i/o on boats between 23-30' but as they make bigger OB's, more go to the OB on newer boats. Or, with bigger boats, you go to direct drive since you run them in deeper water.
 

Taxus812

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
177
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Wow really cool information. Thank You.
That makes much more sense. (I was referring to Bass boats when I said "fishing" boats :) )

I purchased my boat with specific requirements. Since I live inland a bit. I planned on using it in the CT river which opens up into long island sound (about an hour or so by river south from me). I also primarily run it in my back yard sorta speak in another river that is dammed into a small reservoir. (both have lots of debris and shallows)

I selected the bowrider (fish and ski) for my families desired activities
I also got it with an outboard because I could raise the motor out of the water and hoped it would be easier to work on\maintain.

I am very happy with my decision (since it meets my needs), but since all I see around here is I/O and was wondering if outboards were not a desirable thing (affecting resale).

Glad to see it is regional
 

H20Rat

Vice Admiral
Joined
Mar 8, 2009
Messages
5,204
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

As others mentioned, depends entirely on region. In my area, bowriders with I/O's are generally the more popular option. The sundeck and the swim platform are the big selling feature, as well as the noise level of an outboard vs I/O. (yes, even 4 stroke outboards are loud compared to a well insulated I/O) (of course, pontoons with outboards outsell all other boats 10:1, so there are far more outboards sold. I'm just talking bowrider type boats)

This is entirely speculation based on observation and experiences, but I/O's tend to deal with short seasons and infrequent use better, and are more tolerant of spending more time in storage. Outboards seem to have lots of carb and seal issues from being dried out. The more you use an outboard, the better.
 
Last edited:

oldjeep

Admiral
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
6,455
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Depends on the area. Locally, everyone wants an outboard or an inboard (saltwater). You can't give an I/O away.

And the opposite is pretty true here in MN, unless it is a fishing boat. An outboard powered bowrider is a rarity here and when you do see one they are usually 20+ years old.
 

crabby captain john

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
1,823
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

I/Os are rare here in the salt. All my charter boats on the Great Lakes were I/Os but would not have one here at the coast.
 

foodfisher

Captain
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Messages
3,756
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Stern drive- Doesn't that mean fixed prop with a rudder?
 

JoLin

Vice Admiral
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
5,146
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Stern drive- Doesn't that mean fixed prop with a rudder?

You're describing an inboard. Stern drive and I/O are just 2 different terms for the same drive arrangement
 

jkust

Rear Admiral
Joined
Aug 2, 2008
Messages
4,942
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

And the opposite is pretty true here in MN, unless it is a fishing boat. An outboard powered bowrider is a rarity here and when you do see one they are usually 20+ years old.

Totally agree. I/O's have ruled the day for a long time now on Bowriders here in MN. I do recall the days when I/O's were the rarity back in the 80's though. I would only want an OB bowrider as a second bowrider. Here if you want an OB it's going to generally be a fishing boat or pontoon with a few exceptions here and there both old and new. I would say then that that local scenario will play a part in resale value.
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,897
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

The sundeck and the swim platform are the big selling feature, as well as the noise level of an outboard vs I/O. (yes, even 4 stroke outboards are loud compared to a well insulated I/O)
Humm.. it looks like the I/O is not the quietest at 1500 rpm nor WOT, with only a slight advantage in the mid-range.

Mercrusier 135HP: 1500 rpm - 71 dBA....... 29.3 MPH = 80 dBA..... 43.7 MPH = 94 dBA

Honda BF150 4 stroke outboard:1500 rpm - 70.5 dBA....... 27.6 MPH = 84.5 dBA..... 42.9 MPH = 92 dBA

E-TEC 150 2 stroke outboard:1500 rpm - 75 dBA....... 29. MPH = 84 dBA..... 48.8 MPH = 97 dBA
 

Taxus812

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
177
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Honestly,
At higher speeds the wind is all I hear. Low speeds its not much of an issue either
 

oldjeep

Admiral
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
6,455
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Humm.. it looks like the I/O is not the quietest at 1500 rpm nor WOT, with only a slight advantage in the mid-range.

Mercrusier 135HP: 1500 rpm - 71 dBA....... 29.3 MPH = 80 dBA..... 43.7 MPH = 94 dBA

Honda BF150 4 stroke outboard:1500 rpm - 70.5 dBA....... 27.6 MPH = 84.5 dBA..... 42.9 MPH = 92 dBA

E-TEC 150 2 stroke outboard:1500 rpm - 75 dBA....... 29. MPH = 84 dBA..... 48.8 MPH = 97 dBA

It would be interesting to know how they came up with standard numbers for an I/O since the noise is directly related to how it is installed in the boat and how insulated the engine compartment is.

Where did you get those results?
 

25thmustang

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Mar 20, 2008
Messages
1,849
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

Being that I'm on the same river as you, I will say there are probably more I/O boats than outboards. Even down near the sound there seem to be a lot of I/Os.
 

H20Rat

Vice Admiral
Joined
Mar 8, 2009
Messages
5,204
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

It would be interesting to know how they came up with standard numbers for an I/O since the noise is directly related to how it is installed in the boat and how insulated the engine compartment is.

Where did you get those results?

Curious where those came from... At last count, I've owned about 9 outboard powered boats, some 2, some 4 stroke, and 4 different inboards. The inboards have all been DRAMATICALLY quieter than the outboards. Although its still worth mentioning, the etec is twice as loud as the inboard...
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,897
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

It would be interesting to know how they came up with standard numbers for an I/O since the noise is directly related to how it is installed in the boat and how insulated the engine compartment is.

Where did you get those results?
The same can be said for an outboard. A bracket mounted outboard is much noticeably quieter than one mounted directly to the boat

One from boat test the other from power boat reports.

Playing - Bayliner 175 Bowrider - | Bayliner | Powered By BoatTest.com

[url]http://continuouswave.com/ubb/Forum4/HTML/004482.html

[/URL]
 

oldjeep

Admiral
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
6,455
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

The same can be said for an outboard. A bracket mounted outboard is much noticeably quieter than one mounted directly to the boat

One from boat test the other from power boat reports.

Playing - Bayliner 175 Bowrider - | Bayliner | Powered By BoatTest.com

[url]http://continuouswave.com/ubb/Forum4/HTML/004482.html

[/URL]

OK, so you used data from a boat where one of the most common modifications is to add some sound insulation to the plastic engine cover ;)
 

jkust

Rear Admiral
Joined
Aug 2, 2008
Messages
4,942
Re: Which has a higher resale value Outboard or Stern Drive

OK, so you used data from a boat where one of the most common modifications is to add some sound insulation to the plastic engine cover ;)

It looked like there was no sound insulation at all in the Bayliner engine cover? Plus are 3.0 louder than 4.3's for instance? I can hear the whine from a long ways away from shore. Maybe just because it is not as deep a pitch.
 
Top