Silvertip
Supreme Mariner
- Joined
- Sep 22, 2003
- Messages
- 28,771
Re: Bad gas
That would depend on the design of the ignition and fuel systems on your BMW. Modern engines are fitted with knock sensors. Should spark knock (preignition) be detected by the knock sensor, timing is retarded to eliminate the problem. Therefore, reduced timing = less power = poorer mileage. Higher octane fuel allows the timing to be advanced farther than with 89 octane. Case in point. My Impala is a flex fuel vehicle. It performs better on E-85 than E-10 because E-85 has 104 octane. The down side is mileage goes down about 3 mpg because of the difference in "energy" in the fuel. Injector timing changes automatically to compensate for the increased fuel demand. All of this means that if your engine is designed to run on 89 octane that's all it needs. There is no advantage to running premium unless as I said, the engine has a knock sensor and the electronics allow for increased timing beyond what 89 octane requires.
Would that explain why my BMW gets worse MPG with 89 and better with 93 where as my Chrysler seams to get worse MPG with 93 and better with 89?
That would depend on the design of the ignition and fuel systems on your BMW. Modern engines are fitted with knock sensors. Should spark knock (preignition) be detected by the knock sensor, timing is retarded to eliminate the problem. Therefore, reduced timing = less power = poorer mileage. Higher octane fuel allows the timing to be advanced farther than with 89 octane. Case in point. My Impala is a flex fuel vehicle. It performs better on E-85 than E-10 because E-85 has 104 octane. The down side is mileage goes down about 3 mpg because of the difference in "energy" in the fuel. Injector timing changes automatically to compensate for the increased fuel demand. All of this means that if your engine is designed to run on 89 octane that's all it needs. There is no advantage to running premium unless as I said, the engine has a knock sensor and the electronics allow for increased timing beyond what 89 octane requires.