Do you believe people can change?

wildmaninal

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
1,897
OK I just was wanting to get some views from some of you iboaters out there..

I've been in a couple of situations where even though I'm old enough to make my own dicisions, relatives have tried to steer me the otherway. I've met a couple of ladies throughout the years, one of them I dated and the other I just met a little while back.

The first one after a while was messed up on drugs and really turned out to be (for lack of a better word) a tramp. This one I let go a few years back and from what I understand she hasn't changed. She had kids which lived with her mom. This one was partially responsible for putting me in trouble's way, and I also had money owed because of her. My father wouldn't have anything to do with me at the time I was seeing her.

This other lady that I met just recently was in trouble with the law in the past (2times) that I know of, been clean for good a while now, does drink occasionally (which I do myself) and has money owed that she is trying to take care of. We've been job searching together for a few weeks now, so I know for a fact that she is trying to better herself at least in some ways. Just last night she asked me out, so we went out and had a good time. She seems to be pretty smart, even though she didn't graduate highschool. She does have kids, but they are mainly with her x-husband. From what I hear from her she doesn't mind fishing so......

Now I have relatives that just because these certain people have had a troubled past, they think that I should stay away from this latest one also, in other words they think I can do better. But I've had some troubles in my past also and I can not for the life of me be a hypocrite and deny the fact that I've been through some of the same type of things they have been through. At the same time I believe that nobody can walk in other peoples shoes and know what those people have been through though. I've changed my troubled ways years ago and I don't mind being around some one that has had a little bit of a troubled past and is trying to better themselves.

Nobody in my family seems to understand that people can and do change, some people were raised in a rough or not so perfect environment. Some people can't see when somebody is trying to better themselves. Reminds me of the 1700s and 1800s, where you have the upper class people that would not let their kids play with or date the lower class people, which still happens today but not as bad as back then.

I also half to ask......

Where or why could this make for a bad relationship, maybe even if it was just friends?

Your thoughts otherwise.
 
D

DJ

Guest
Re: Do you believe people can change?

People can change and I give them that chance.

HOWEVER, nothing speaks louder than a track record showing that change.

A "Catch 22" I realize but it is reality.
 

mthieme

Captain
Joined
Oct 6, 2007
Messages
3,270
Re: Do you believe people can change?

I'm sorry, but I have a more cynical outlook.
It has been my unfortunate experience that people do not change.
It takes some people longer than others to grow-up.
My opinion does not count though.
I would highly encourage you to learn about co-dependency.
It sounds like you've fallen into this trap and need to be able to recognize and deal with (if not avoid) this.
You are more important than a relationship.
Hope things turn out for you.
 

wildmaninal

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
1,897
Re: Do you believe people can change?

People can change and I give them that chance.

HOWEVER, nothing speaks louder than a track record showing that change.

A "Catch 22" I realize but it is reality.

Yep you make a good point about the track record...... As for the track record of this latest girl, I would say for one thing she's been job searching, another is that she is staying at my uncle's place where they are half way decent people. My devorced cousin and her are friends, they are just trying to help her out as well. She's also been keeping on top of her legal problems.
 
D

DJ

Guest
Re: Do you believe people can change?

Yep...... As for the track record of this latest girl, I would say for one thing she's been job searching, another is that she is staying at my uncle's place where they are half way decent people. My devorced cousin and her are friends, they are just trying to help her out as well. She's also been keeping on top of her legal problems.

A "job search" and a job are two different things. A search can last forever. No offense.

Involvement and freindship can be two different things. I would stay at arms length until you see definite progress.
 

lowkee

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 13, 2008
Messages
1,890
Re: Do you believe people can change?

I'm with mthieme 95%. Your story, to my partially trained eye, sounds co-dependancy alarms with a touch of 'comfort'. Without going into dirty detail, I'd say it's a good time to shoot higher and expect more even if that means being single for longer than you would like. The extra time is well spent working to identify and improve the patterns in your own behavior. Once you do this, you will (over time) raise your standards naturally and in a fair manner (ie: you won't expect more from others than you give or have yourself).

I lack the 5% agreement only because people can and do change, it simply takes time and a lot of it. Life changes happen over years, not weeks or months, this includes personality (habit) changes. Stay single, find work, get stable, learn about yourself and you'll discover living the life you look for in others will greatly ease the search for the person you want.
 

jonesg

Admiral
Joined
Feb 22, 2008
Messages
7,198
Re: Do you believe people can change?

Ditto,
what we do shouts louder than the words we say.

When I see a mother without custody of her children ...something pretty bad happened in the eyes of a judge. It had to be significant.

People can change, but they can also want to want ,
and appear to change without really changing,
in other words they can act good and honestly WANT to be better but invariably fall back into old ways because they don't have the constitution to be honest with themself at a fundamental level.

Maybe step back and look at the bigger picture.
Is it possible theres a pattern in your choice of women here?
Do you think you can help them?
If this woman is trying to change, where is she placing her ultimate reliance?
 

chiefalen

Captain
Joined
May 18, 2008
Messages
3,598
Re: Do you believe people can change?

A good woman is hard to find.

Was your mother a good woman ?

All goes back to when we were children.

You have to understand what you really want.

Want a good woman, you know in your inner self what that means to you.

Good luck young man, found my woman 22 years ago today i married her.

And have 4 wonderful children she gave me.
 

pduquette

Ensign
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
Messages
999
Re: Do you believe people can change?

Hey Wildmanimal , I'm 42 + divorced ; so prettymuch in the same boat . Seems like every woman round here is looking for a free ride . I'm not too strict in what I'm looking for , but firmly belive a good woman will do everything she can to uplift " her man " to make both your lives the best that you can have . As soon as the " Me first " princess shows up ,It's time to pack up . I guess I'm saying , most of the time people hide who they are , but I believe they CAN change if the desire/reward is strong enough .
If your friend is good to you , procede with caution and see what happens. And if your relatives want to be SOOO helpful...why ain't the sending those hidden jems your way ?? With 16 aunts + uncles (not including spouses) not one has ever said to me "Hey I'd like you to meet....." Sound Familiar??:D
 

eaglejim

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
1,006
Re: Do you believe people can change?

You are what you hang around,I have a SIL that has been looking for a job the last 10 years,she always says she is changing but all her sister and I see is her finding a sugar daddy and that is sad but he is an enabler so there is nothing we can do. But the judge got her into a neat little program.There is nothing wrong with being her friend and lifting her up but after that look elsewhere.Hope that helps
 

F14CRAZY

Ensign
Joined
Aug 12, 2008
Messages
945
Re: Do you believe people can change?

I'm 21 BTW...

I've personally seen friends (not close friends but still friends) ride the long slide down...become alcoholics, take up smoking cigarettes and weed, stealing all the time (alcohol included)...hell one person in that group worked at 7-11 and said their boss was saying that like $1100 worth of alcohol was missing in a month...the boss figured that prices weren't labeled right :rolleyes:. They were able to avoid the security cameras and walk out with tons of alcohol, and no they weren't of legal drinking age. And they're hard drinkers too and hosted parties all the time. They had 70 people at their new year's party last year in the house they rented.

One of my close (female) friends that was/is friends with a girl in that group (she isn't like that herself) even remarked that she looked like a "cheap *****" in some Myspace photos. Doesn't hold a steady job, no college, moved back home...

I don't know how this info helps you, or if it does at all. I feel that people can change. The girl I'm talking about in particular here is saying she's working on changing. Will she? I believe in the good in everyone and would like to think she would, but she's said it before...
 

Kiwi Phil

Commander
Joined
Jun 23, 2003
Messages
2,182
Re: Do you believe people can change?

I've been thinking about your situation Wildanimal, and you have it completely around the wrong way mate, but not to worry, so has 70% of the males in this world.
I certainly don't mean to be rude here.

I wonder if it isn't you that needs to change.
I get the feeling you are looking for a partner.

Lets look at your situation differently.
Why don't you pretend to think like a woman for the next month.
And as this woman, you are looking for a bloke......right????
What are you looking for?
When you see some bu-m in the gutter, do you think, "poor bloke, he's looking for a job and can't get one, he's been in trouble with the law, know body understands him, etc etc.....hull, come with me Bluey, I'll help you, and you will change in to my Prince".
No way, you make sure you never walk down that street again.

But this is what you are looking for as a woman.
(1st think about this...a group of women being a bit scatty......one asks what they would like in a husband.....bingo..."a millionaire, tall and handsome, with a nice car and house and brings me home chocalates and champagne etc etc".....and all the others start giggling in agreement).
You are looking for someone to save your scrawny arxe.

This is the basic difference between man and woman......the man is stupid, the woman smart.

My point is:
people mostly are what they are born to, and genetics don't change, so why look down for a partner that may change to meet your level, why not look up.

What is wrong with finding a highly intellegent woman with grace and dignity and intelligence, self assured, a career, direction and future.
They are out there, and they too need partners.
You may be expected to make a few changes yourself, that's never impossible??? ....is it?????.

See women know, that if they flash their brizillian commando in front of a guy,....pufff....it's all but over. You try flashing your middle wicket and the responce will be quite different.

Go out, have fun, be young, but whatever you do, always aim to go over the bar, not under it, because once on the other side, you are there for a long time.

Can people change???.....Can you Change????....if you have any doubts, then you have answered your own question.

I have been there.
Good luck.

Cheers
Phillip
 

tashasdaddy

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Nov 11, 2005
Messages
51,019
Re: Do you believe people can change?

i have been single since 1980, married 13 years. i have had several relationships over the years. but most turned out to be "Me First" " what you can do for me" i always worked, supported myself, and one of my priorities was my partner also worked. even though i may have provided the home, cars, etc, they need their own money to spend as they please.

you need to get yourself stable, before launching into a serious relationship. your Alabama, Mama, ain't gonna take it lightly, when she gets up in the morning, and your girl friend walks out.
 

wildmaninal

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
1,897
Re: Do you believe people can change?

A "job search" and a job are two different things. A search can last forever. No offense.

Involvement and freindship can be two different things. I would stay at arms length until you see definite progress.

From what I understand......Today she is checking into one of these deals where she knows people that knows people that might be able to get her a job at certain places. After the experience I had with the last girl I dated years ago, I'm going to play "hard to get", and keep everything under a microscope and fine tooth comb. It is nice to have somebody think of me in the ways that she does. As said I enjoy being around her.

Ditto,
what we do shouts louder than the words we say.

When I see a mother without custody of her children ...something pretty bad happened in the eyes of a judge. It had to be significant.

People can change, but they can also want to want ,
and appear to change without really changing,
in other words they can act good and honestly WANT to be better but invariably fall back into old ways because they don't have the constitution to be honest with themself at a fundamental level.

Maybe step back and look at the bigger picture.
Is it possible theres a pattern in your choice of women here?
Do you think you can help them?
If this woman is trying to change, where is she placing her ultimate reliance?

I don't know of any pattern in my choice for a woman right off. I know at my age it is going to be hard to find a woman without any kids . Heck I had a 42 year old woman chasing me around when I worked at one job, but I didn't go for it.

A good woman is hard to find.

Was your mother a good woman ?Inserted by Wildmaninal that would of been harder to answer if you said perfect instead of good. The answer is yes

All goes back to when we were children.

You have to understand what you really want.

Want a good woman, you know in your inner self what that means to you.

Good luck young man, found my woman 22 years ago today i married her.

And have 4 wonderful children she gave me.

Hard to believe my brother has been married 18 years give or take. Congrats on being together for 22 years. My brother's wife was not and is not perfect by anymeans, there are things that I wont mention. Oddly enough she was married to somebody my aunts x-husbands side, so my aunt knows how my sis n law is. Now my sis n law was raised to think lying was alright. There has been many things that my sis n law and I have had disagreements on, some of them I mentioned to my brother in which his reply was "that is just the way she is, she isn't going to change".

Hey Wildmanimal , I'm 42 + divorced ; so prettymuch in the same boat . Seems like every woman round here is looking for a free ride . I'm not too strict in what I'm looking for , but firmly belive a good woman will do everything she can to uplift " her man " to make both your lives the best that you can have . As soon as the " Me first " princess shows up ,It's time to pack up . I guess I'm saying , most of the time people hide who they are , but I believe they CAN change if the desire/reward is strong enough .
If your friend is good to you , procede with caution and see what happens. And if your relatives want to be SOOO helpful...why ain't the sending those hidden jems your way ?? With 16 aunts + uncles (not including spouses) not one has ever said to me "Hey I'd like you to meet....." Sound Familiar??:D

DUDE You have nearly the same amount of aunts and uncles that I have. Years ago my brother tried to set me up a couple of times but he doesn't seem to care anymore, ALTHOUGH he was curious enought to find out about my date with this lady. Which I'm sure his reply to me email to him isn't going to be positive even though I told him I had a good time. You are so right, nobody seems to care enough to hook me up with anybody. Although my cousin's daughter (11 years old :D) did sort of play match maker to the lady that in subject, any how his daughter was sort of rooting for her to ask me. My neices (also 11 years old), has said that she would like to find somebody to hook me up with.

I jokingly said to this man when standing in front of my date at the bar when he wanted me to ask for a beer from his friend which they did offer me a beer but I didn't take it, anyhow he wanted me to get a beer and give it to him which I didn't do but I said "this isn't going to get my arse whipped is it". The man replied no. But my date said something to the affect "oh nobody is going to whoop your arse if I have any say in it". I didn't mean to show any sign of weakness in front of her I was just joking, but there were 4 of those guys and only 1 of me. Although I am crippled up/handicapped and don't know how well I could handle myself in a fight.

I'm 21 BTW...

I've personally seen friends (not close friends but still friends) ride the long slide down...become alcoholics, take up smoking cigarettes and weed, stealing all the time (alcohol included)...hell one person in that group worked at 7-11 and said their boss was saying that like $1100 worth of alcohol was missing in a month...
I don't know how this info helps you, or if it does at all. I feel that people can change. The girl I'm talking about in particular here is saying she's working on changing. Will she? I believe in the good in everyone and would like to think she would, but she's said it before...

Just to make a note to you guys out there, my troubles didn't involve stealing or the law. I also believe in the good in everyone. The first girl that I eventually let go was a trip to be with when she was straight, found out she had a bigger problem she is bypolar, you talk about women that have mood swings, this girl had some mood swings. It all added up at the end and like I said I let her go.

I've been thinking about your situation Wildanimal, and you have it completely around the wrong way mate, but not to worry, so has 70% of the males in this world.
I certainly don't mean to be rude here.

I wonder if it isn't you that needs to change.
I get the feeling you are looking for a partner.

Lets look at your situation differently.
Why don't you pretend to think like a woman for the next month.
And as this woman, you are looking for a bloke......right????
What are you looking for?
When you see some bu-m in the gutter, do you think, "poor bloke, he's looking for a job and can't get one, he's been in trouble with the law, know body understands him, etc etc.....hull, come with me Bluey, I'll help you, and you will change in to my Prince".
No way, you make sure you never walk down that street again.

But this is what you are looking for as a woman.
(1st think about this...a group of women being a bit scatty......one asks what they would like in a husband.....bingo..."a millionaire, tall and handsome, with a nice car and house and brings me home chocalates and champagne etc etc".....and all the others start giggling in agreement).
You are looking for someone to save your scrawny arxe.

This is the basic difference between man and woman......the man is stupid, the woman smart.Inserted by Wildmaninal As you mentioned below they also have an advantage over us, or key to front door if you will
My point is:
people mostly are what they are born to, and genetics don't change, so why look down for a partner that may change to meet your level, why not look up.

What is wrong with finding a highly intellegent woman with grace and dignity and intelligence, self assured, a career, direction and future.
They are out there, and they too need partners.
You may be expected to make a few changes yourself, that's never impossible??? ....is it?????.

See women know, that if they flash their brizillian commando in front of a guy,....pufff....it's all but over. You try flashing your middle wicket and the responce will be quite different. Inserted By wildmaninal Now that is so darn funny but so darn true Also note: OMG at the body she has:redface:, she does have a fine figure

Go out, have fun, be young, but whatever you do, always aim to go over the bar, not under it, because once on the other side, you are there for a long time.

Can people change???.....Can you Change????....if you have any doubts, then you have answered your own question.

I have been there.
Good luck.

Cheers
Phillip

Yes I have made alot of changes in my behavior and all, some things have plummeted down the drain.......Like for instance I have social anxiety, and being with or around this lady has really helped me get out and be at ease even before I went on this date with her which by the way I took her to a bar. Once we got to the bar she kept her focus on me and nothing else.

I may have more changing to do myself, I can't put my finger right on or speak of any other problems I have at the moment besides one the fact that I smoke.

I was mainly using the "some people were raised in a rough or not so perfect environment" as an example. I don't know the whole story as to how this woman was raised.

I may have more to respond to on these posts so please don't think I've short handed any of you on responses but for now I've got to get some rest.


I'm with mthieme 95%. Your story, to my partially trained eye, sounds co-dependancy alarms with a touch of 'comfort'. Without going into dirty detail, I'd say it's a good time to shoot higher and expect more even if that means being single for longer than you would like. The extra time is well spent working to identify and improve the patterns in your own behavior. Once you do this, you will (over time) raise your standards naturally and in a fair manner (ie: you won't expect more from others than you give or have yourself).

I lack the 5% agreement only because people can and do change, it simply takes time and a lot of it. Life changes happen over years, not weeks or months, this includes personality (habit) changes. Stay single, find work, get stable, learn about yourself and you'll discover living the life you look for in others will greatly ease the search for the person you want.


You know that when a majority of the people that are married or have a relationship or a friend and they get to the point I'm at, which I'm am unemployed etc etc........ they have been known to get a divorce, or for the ones with a relationship or just friends they have parted ways because of the difficult times.

What I find interesting about this girl that I just met, she knows I'm unemployed, she finds me to be cute, and also says I'm a gentlemen (said that in front of some of my relatives). In otherwords she's interested in me, I know she isn't interested in my job or big paycheck because I don't have one. Now who knows....this girl I met might lose interest in me, or she might find something about me that will make her throw on the brakes. She is 5 years older then me, which is fine, I set the limit at 8 years above or below me.

Now the girl I dated and split up with in the past new I had a decent paying job, nice truck, nice apartment etc etc, and she took advantage of me in the long run.
 

Shizzy

Ensign
Joined
Aug 5, 2007
Messages
984
Re: Do you believe people can change?

Shortly after getting divorced and having a string of worthless women come my way I realized my standards were way too low. I had to decide if I was just going for a quick ride or if I was looking for a long term partner. I decided I had enough of drinking and funny business. I would quit seeing a girl at the first sign of stupidity. Most girls made it about 2 weeks at the longest. I had a long list of basic requirements.

Must have a job. I didnt car what, just have and keep a job.
NOT living with parents or relatives. she could be renting a room from a friend or own a house, I didnt care.
Own a car. could be a rusty pile of bolts, I didnt care.
drinking and smoking only in moderation. no drugs, no drunks and no chain smokers.
Must have a checking account. again, dont care if there is $13 in the account, but yo umust show you can handle it.

these simple rules excluded 9 out of 10 girls out there. the 9 were fun till you got what you needed, but then they were of no use to me.

I dated a girl who had in the past done her share of drugs. I told her from day one If she does any of that garbage to not even call me. She was clean while we where dating, and I treated her like a queen, but one day she quit calling. I knew and she knew. She picked drugs over me and that was that. to this day no hard feelings, we bump in to each other once in a while and she has been clean for 4 years now, but too late.

People can change IF THEY WANT THE CHANGE. I used to be a drunken womanizing arseclown but now I only have a beer here and there and have been seeing the same girl for over 4 years now.
 

gonefishie

Commander
Joined
Jul 28, 2004
Messages
2,624
Re: Do you believe people can change?

You should take Phil's words as bible, they're very true. Set your expectation high but don't go too far beyond your own league. Some will disagree with me on this but there are definetely different levels of playing field. Like Phil said, you have to see things from a perspective of a woman looking for a mate/partner. In the end, your relationship is your business, your decision, your consequences. Take others advices into consideration but don't let them totally dictate your decision. It's your life man, live how you want it and be ready to accept the consequences. Happiness is all in how one defines it. Whatever float your boat!
 

F14CRAZY

Ensign
Joined
Aug 12, 2008
Messages
945
Re: Do you believe people can change?

Just to make a note to you guys out there, my troubles didn't involve stealing or the law. I also believe in the good in everyone. The first girl that I eventually let go was a trip to be with when she was straight, found out she had a bigger problem she is bypolar, you talk about women that have mood swings, this girl had some mood swings. It all added up at the end and like I said I let her go.

I do understand. Was just tossing that in there as another bad situation someone was in that required change.

Any I feel you there on the bipolar part. My ex was able to hide the fact that she was bipolar, and bisexual, for over a year...small wonder it was so hard to keep her around
 

aspeck

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
May 29, 2003
Messages
19,099
Re: Do you believe people can change?

Can a person change? Yes, they can, if they want to change. But old habits are not easily broken and it takes time to change and to prove yourself.

From the sounds of your posts (and I could be ALL wrong, and if I am, please forgive me) this woman has had some recent issues that she is still dealing with. Obviously if she is still dealing with them, she hasn't had enough time to prove a true change in habits and patterns.

My advice would be to keep your relationship to a friendship level. No touching, nothing physical, don't do anything more with her than you would your fishing or boating buddy. From your posts it sounds like she is a good looker and interested in you, so it could be easy to let the hormones run wild and hormones have a way of clouding your vision.

Stand back and watch how she interacts with others. See how she handles her kids, her finances, etc. Make sure the changes are real and genuine. After time, if there are romantic feelings and you have observed the desired characteristics displayed in her actions, then you can move your friendship to another level.

Personal story ... I have been married almost 9 years now. Was 38 when I married. I knew the girl I married for about 12 years before we married. She was divorced, had 2 kids, and before we met did not have some of the qualities that I felt were important. But gosh was she cute! Anyway, we became friends, but I never let her know that I was interested. I watched her. When we did things together it was in a group setting, just a bunch of us getting together having some fun. I watched her get her GED. I watched her go on to business school and then get a decent job in the accounting department of a local business. I watched her handle her money and deal with her kids. I saw her get out of debt and become very self sufficient. I saw how she handled herself in different situations and I liked what I saw. Apparently she liked what she saw on this end, because we got engaged ... the day she said yes was the first time we even held hands! But I didn't have to deal with the emotional baggage to cloud my judgement. I don't know how I survived without her. She is a true gem ... a polished diamond.

So, yes, people can change. But watch from a distance and make sure she wants to change and has changed before getting hooked by your emotions.
 

waterinthefuel

Commander
Joined
Nov 15, 2003
Messages
2,728
Re: Do you believe people can change?

Aspeck you are a wise man.

Lots of good advice in this thread.
 

gonefishie

Commander
Joined
Jul 28, 2004
Messages
2,624
Re: Do you believe people can change?

And a lucky one too. Most women's biological clock ticks loudly and they don't like waiting, let alone 12 yrs.

Oh yeah, wildmanimal. Never go into a relationship and expect to change the other party with much success. Their attitude, habits, etc.. is what make who they are. When those things change they become someone else and most don't like it and become unhappy. When they're unhappy, you won't be either. If you can't except her for who she is right now then look the other way. Just imagine, what if a woman want you to quit fishing because she thinks it's a bad habit. Would you be happy about that?
 
Top