Mercury vs Hond***

misturdan

Recruit
Joined
Nov 12, 2002
Messages
2
Re: Mercury vs Hond***

Hey scorpio,<br />just incase you haven't made up your mind, <br />My momma didn't raise the smartest egg in the carton, evidence is I have 3 7.5hp Honda carcasas behind my shed. I bought 2 of them (used) The third belongs to a buddy and I voided myself of a 4th when I sold my 22 Catalina. It was a 5hp, and the worst of the bunch. Cathodic errosion claimed the cases on 2 of the 7.5s The 5 I bought from a dealer, but knew the original owner. He was meticulas about his boat and hadn't mistreated the unit. I picked it up on the premis that the pull starter needed repaired. Truth is the cast drive gear on the flywheel had disentigrated (dissimilar metals) I' guessing here, but just the same, my long dead grandpa in his grave had better structural qualities, not to mention that Honda likes you to bend over, way over when you buy parts from them...and you MUST buy parts from them <br />It died from an exhaust caused corroded hole on the bottom of the crankcase, when the crankcase pressure increased(engine rpm increase) it'd spew it's lubricant all over Sarasota bay until the low oil shut down would kill the engine.<br />I could go on, but I think you got the message, I replaced it with a 9.9 johnson 4 stroke, never had to push the boat off the bottom again, what a pleasure to own and operate. One last note, I bought a 1976 Merc 7.5 for my dinghy, it runssssss, God but that little guy runs. All I can say is, honda...bad, baaaaddddddddddd. Good luck <br />dan
 

Scorpio

Cadet
Joined
Sep 21, 2002
Messages
25
Re: Mercury vs Hond***

Thanks for your replies. Yes NOW WHAT ?<br />Do I look at another 50 or 60 EFI Merc ?( I had a 40 carb), Or do I take the $$$ and run to another<br />dealership ? I got real mixed views on this one.<br />When you've been burnt bad your afraid of little fires. :confused:
 

butlp

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Feb 26, 2002
Messages
302
Re: Mercury vs Hond***

Scorpio,<br />Congratulations on the outcome!<br />You know my view, very happy with the Merc. 50 EFI, 60 would be nice too. I think you will see a big difference to the carb motor.<br /><br />Really comes down to service in your area. Your Merc dealer did eventually come through, better the devil you know! I'd give him one more chance.
 

BillP

Captain
Joined
Aug 10, 2002
Messages
3,290
Re: Mercury vs Hond***

I have a mariner (merc/yamaha) 50 4s and wouldn't buy another merc product. It runs fine and given no problems but construction isn't impressive. Lots of rinky dink plastic parts...hose clamps are tie wraps (one came off and pixxed h20 into the rear cowling), water pump impeller is fragile and small (almost exact same size as my 1951 johnson 3 impeller), cheap trim switch,etc...it has a lot of visible "cost cutting" to save merc $15 on a $5600 motor. I bought the engine new in 96. <br /><br />Buy anything but the merc.
 
Top