It all depends on what you're planning to do with your boat...and All boats are compromises anyway!....
I do agree with your statement to a point, depending on who you are and what you're expectations are.
"I own a 14' tinny, that actually I don't own any more because I gave it to my son. Its a modified V, "rugged duty" that is a little wider and deeper than most.
Back in the day we filled her to capacity with 2 adults and 2 pre-teen boys. I originally bought it as a utilty trailer to transport our tent and camping gear and then have a boat when we got to the lake. Well, the lake got boring so we ended up in rivers and some Great Lakes campgrounds and even with the 4 of it it never let us down.
If we had to navigate skinny water way up in the inlets to get the big bass, she worked there too.
Yeah, all are a compromise, but my little Sea Nymph met all her requirements and then some.