What to do with old starter motor

sidechoke67

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Oct 24, 2007
Messages
244
I had a starter that was kind of flakey - working sometimes and not others. I went through Don's check list when it wasn't starting, and that indicated that the problem is the starter itself - the circuit test lights came on when testing the solenoid while turning the key but the engine still didn't turn over. Then tapping the starter/solenoid while turning the key got it to engage and start.

Our summers are pretty short here in upstate NY, so I ended up buying and installing a new starter. All is well with my boat now.

My question is what to do with the old starter. I took it to AutoZone and it passed their test - the guy there even ran through the test 5 times in a row when I told him it had an intermittent problem. Still though, I wouldn't trust the starter as it is to put it in my boat. I could try to get it re-built and keep
it as a spare....but I'm hoping to get several years at least out of my new
starter. I could try to sell it, but wouldn't have a clue how to price a marine starter that works sometimes...not sure if it is worth getting it rebuilt just to sell it?

Anyone have any thoughts?

TIA.
 

Limited-Time

Vice Admiral
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
5,820
Re: What to do with old starter motor

Have it rebuilt and keep it for a spare. Or e-bay it for what you can get for it. Just be sure to describe it as you did here.
 

sidechoke67

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Oct 24, 2007
Messages
244
Re: What to do with old starter motor

Good advice, thanks.

If I have it rebuilt and keep it around as a spare, will it "go bad" if it ends up sitting around for 5 - 10 years before I need it?
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,089
Re: What to do with old starter motor

will it "go bad" if it ends up sitting around for 5 - 10 years before I need it?

Nope,... Not as long as it's kept Dry...

I took it to AutoZone and it passed their test - the guy there even ran through the test 5 times in a row when I told him it had an intermittent problem.

Ayuh,....
My WAGuess is,.... There's Nothing wrong with it....
It had a Bad Ground,... which you disturbed,+ inadvertently Fixed by changing the starter...
 

sidechoke67

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Oct 24, 2007
Messages
244
Re: What to do with old starter motor

My WAGuess is,.... There's Nothing wrong with it....
It had a Bad Ground,... which you disturbed,+ inadvertently Fixed by changing the starter...

Yea...I guess that is possible - although I went through circuit diagnostics while it wasn't starting and the circuit light came on at the solenoid when I turned the key.
 
Top