I guess I confused "personal favorite" with "best". I do think that the 9.5 was a great functioning motor when they were current and in production, but for all the reasons you state (well stated BTW) they are not a collector favorite. I never did see the starter rope as a common malady with these motors however; maybe I have just been lucky. Keep an open mind as it is only my opinion.I enjoyed reading TN's post and am with all you guys on everything but the 9.5hp johnson. As far as the small OMC's, I think it was the worst they ever made. Reason: #1 UGLY #2 Exhaust seals/PITA to work on #3 Motor mounts #4 Poorly designed recoil starter that wears out cords really quickly #5 The darned thing wasn't within 1/2hp of the previous 10hp motors in my opinion. #6 AWFUL color combinations
I guess most folks either love 'em or hate 'em.....
I had a hard time finding an image of a 58' 35hp Lark in black but here is a 57' in black which is just as nice and a blue 58 that looks stunning. I don't see the odd look your talking about? Unless you are talking about when they went to the square cowling in 59' I believe?
http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk160/Timtoboyko/images.jpg
http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk160/Timtoboyko/images-1.jpg
I wouldn't mind running across a '57 Lark, myself, even if I have to drag a boat home with it. Those are actually my all time favorites.
Go to this link: http://www.old-omc.de/start.html then select "The 50'ies", then "1958", then "Evinrude brochure". You will be able to see all the 1958 Evinrudes, including the simple 35 horse Big Twin and the 35 horse Lark with the revised "Super Quiet" lower unit and way-out cowling.So Zephyr did they change the cowling in 58'? I have seen 58's with the round style cowling also?
I love the lines of that Sabrecraft! It looks like something out of the Jetsons. (Where do you get all these wonderful toys Zephyr?) I bet that 35 would push it along nicely. A head turner on the water for sure.