Luke, since you asked about changing the seat base topic, which turned into a deck repair, I merged the 2 topics into 1 under the most recently started topic.
The pix you posted are here now.
More pix wouldnt hurt though.
I would put it back similar to how the factory did, just sealed better. If the old deck was supported by the chine, run the new deck over to the chine and bed it just like you should a stringer.
But my initial impression hasnt changed. There was a lot of damage to that seat base and surrounding deck to be an isolated problem. Perhaps it is/was. Thats extremely uncommon though.
I got your PM, but havent replied yet.